Current drug development tends towards complex chemical molecules, referred to as “beyond rule of five” (bRo5) compounds, which often exhibit challenging physicochemical properties. Measuring Caco-2 permeability of those compounds is difficult due to technical limitations, including poor recovery and detection sensitivity. We implemented a novel assay, with optimized incubation and analytics, to measure permeability close to equilibrium. In this setup an appropriate characterization of permeability for bRo5 compounds is achievable. This equilibrated Caco-2 assay was verified with respect to data validity, compound recovery, and in vitro to in vivo correlation for human absorption. Compared to a standard assay, it demonstrated comparable performance in predicting the human fraction absorbed (fa) for reference compounds. The equilibrated assay also successfully characterized the permeability of more than 90% of the compounds analyzed, the majority of which were bRo5 (68%). These compounds could not be measured using the standard assay. Permeability and efflux ratio (ER) were highly predictive for in vivo absorption for a large set of internal bRo5 compounds. Reference cut-offs enabled the correct classification of high, moderate, and low absorption. This optimized equilibrated Caco-2 assay closes the gap for a high-throughput cellular permeability method in the bRo5 chemical space.
The poor solubility and permeability of compounds beyond Lipinski’s Rule of Five (bRo5) are major challenges for cell-based permeability assays. Due to their incompatibility with gastrointestinal components in biorelevant media, the exploration of important questions addressing food effects is limited. Thus, we established a robust mucin-protected Caco-2 assay to allow the assessment of drug permeation in complex biorelevant media. To do that, the assay conditions were first optimized with dependence of the concentration of porcine mucin added to the cells. Mucin-specific effects on drug permeability were evaluated by analyzing cell permeability values for 15 reference drugs (BCS class I–IV). Secondly, a sigmoidal relationship between mucin-dependent permeability and fraction absorbed in human (fa) was established. A case study with venetoclax (BCS class IV) was performed to investigate the impact of medium complexity and the prandial state on drug permeation. Luminal fluids obtained from the tiny-TIM system showed a higher solubilization capacity for venetoclax, and a better read-out for the drug permeability, as compared to FaSSIF or FeSSIF media. In conclusion, the mucin-protected Caco-2 assay combined with biorelevant media improves the mechanistic understanding of drug permeation and addresses complex biopharmaceutical questions, such as food effects on oral drug absorption.
Biopharmaceutical companies generate a wealth of data, ranging from in silico physicochemical properties and machine learning models to both low and high-throughput in vitro assays and in vivo studies. To effectively harnesses this extensive data, we introduce a statistical methodology facilitated by Accuracy, Utility, and Rank Order Assessment (AURA), which combines basic statistical analyses with dynamic data visualizations to evaluate endpoint effectiveness in predicting intestinal absorption. We demonstrated that various physicochemical properties uniquely influence intestinal absorption on a project-specific basis, considering factors like intestinal efflux, passive permeability, and clearance. Projects within both the "Rule of 5" (Ro5) and beyond "Rule of 5" (bRo5) space present unique absorption challenges, emphasizing the need for tailored optimization strategies over one-size-fits-all approaches. This is corroborated by the improved accuracy of project-specific correlations over global models. The differences in correlations between and within project teams-due to their unique chemical spaces-highlight how complex and nuanced the prediction of intestinal absorption can be. Here, we implement a standardized methodology, AURA, that any organization can incorporate into their workflow to enhance early-stage drug optimization. By automating analytics, integrating diverse data types, and offering flexible visualizations, AURA enables cross-functional teams to make data-driven decisions, optimize workflows, and enhance research efficiency.