Sarah Kate Smith

Sarah Kate Smith

orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

10Years (2017-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
19 June 2017 in British Journal of Health Psychology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
TGTim Gomersall
Tim Gomersall
SSSarah Kate Smith
Sarah Kate Smith
CBCharlotte Blewett
Charlotte Blewett
AAArlene Astell
Arlene Astell
Objectives: To understand the perceived benefits and drawbacks of a mild cognitive impairment ( MCI ) diagnosis from the perspective of those living with the label. Methods: Participants were included if they had recently (within 6 months) received a MCI diagnosis. We also recruited close family members to gain their perspectives. Each was interviewed separately with a semi‐structured topic guide covering three areas: (1) experience of cognitive impairments and changes in the individual; (2) impact of cognitive impairment(s) on daily activities and social relationships; and (3) experience of the diagnosis process and living with the label. Transcribed interviews were stored in Nvivo ® . Grounded theory procedures of memo writing, open coding, constant comparison, and focused coding were used to derive conceptual themes. Results: Eighteen dyads were interviewed. The overarching themes surrounding diagnosis benefits and drawbacks were as follows: (1) emotional impact of the diagnosis; (2) practical benefits and limitations of the diagnosis, in terms of (a) understanding one's symptoms and (b) access to clinical support. Although participants were glad to have clinical support in place, they expressed frustration at the lack of clarity, and the lack of available treatments for MCI . Consequently, living with MCI can be characterized as an ambivalent experience. Conclusion: As a clinical label, MCI appears to have little explanatory power for people living with cognitive difficulties. Work is needed to clarify how clinicians and patients communicate about MCI , and how people can be helped to live well with the label. Despite an emerging body of prognostic studies, people with MCI are likely to continue living with significant uncertainty. Statement of contribution: What is already known on this subject? Mild cognitive impairment is a state of cognitive decline between normal cognitive ageing and dementia. This clinical category has been an important domain of academic debate over recent years. From a clinical perspective, diagnosing MCI is a helpful way to enable communication between health professionals, and a diagnosis can be important for patients in need of support and education. However, diagnosis can be fraught with difficulties, while patients have reported significant uncertainty about the label. This study aimed to examine the perceived benefits and drawbacks of receiving a MCI diagnosis. What does this study add? The emotional impact of a MCI diagnosis is complex and raised conflicting and fluctuating emotions in our participants’ accounts – most notably worry and relief. Participants were glad to have clinical support available to call on; however, they were frustrated at the lack of ‘treatments’ available for MCI and were often anxious to slow any cognitive decline down Health psychologists will have an important role to play in understanding and improving clinical communication about MCI

17 March 2021 in Research Involvement and Engagement
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
KBKatherine Broomfield
Katherine Broomfield
CCClaire Louise Craig
Claire Louise Craig
SSSarah Kate Smith
Sarah Kate Smith
GJGeorgina Jones
Georgina Jones
SJSimon Judge
Simon Judge
KSKaren Sage
Karen Sage
Background: The role of public involvement (PI) in healthcare research is growing in importance and it is imperative that researchers continuously reflect on how to promote the inclusion of patients and service users in the design and delivery of research. PI offers a mechanism for end-users to be involved planning, executing, and reporting research. Some patient groups, including people who have communication difficulties, may struggle to engage in the methods traditionally employed to promote PI engagement such as questionnaires and focus groups. Methods: This article describes a longitudinal case-study of a PI group, consisting of people who have communication difficulties, for a patient-reported outcome development project. Creative methods, informed by the participatory design principles of enacting, seeing and doing, were introduced stepwise into seven PI meetings. Data from video and visual minutes were used to evaluate the impact of the methods, following each group. Feedback, in the form of verbal and visual outputs taken directly from group meeting minutes, along with vignettes evidenced the impact of the methods on the project and group members. Results: Creative methods enabled the PI group members to successfully contribute in meetings, to interact dynamically and to engage with the aims and processes of the research project. Their involvement facilitated the development of accessible recruitment materials, informed data analysis and supported the dissemination of project outputs. Employing creative methods also enabled both PI group members and the academic team to reflect on their own roles within the research project and the impact that their active involvement in the PI group has had on their personal development and perspectives on research. Conclusion: The impact of using creative methods in PI for this patient-reported outcome measure (PROM) development project improved collaboration and understanding between PI members and the academic team. The authentic engagement of people who have communication difficulties in PI generated a more accessible project in terms of both process and impact. Creativity has applicability beyond people whose communication is non-verbal; it should be harnessed by research teams to identify and breakdown barriers to involvement to develop outcome tools that reflect the diversity of our populations.

1 January 2021 in Wellbeing, Space and Society
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
SSSarah Kate Smith
Sarah Kate Smith
AIAnthea Innes
Anthea Innes
SBSophie Bushell
Sophie Bushell

6 April 2021 in Health & Social Care in the Community
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
SSSarah Kate Smith
Sarah Kate Smith
AIAnthea Innes
Anthea Innes
SBSophie Bushell
Sophie Bushell
Evidence exists relating to music‐based initiatives and positive health outcomes for people living with dementia who can access them. Yet, knowledge about the impact of ‘music‐making’ on the well‐being of community‐dwelling people with dementia is limited. Much of the existing evidence about the benefits of music is focused on care home settings where initiatives can be readily applied as part of a weekly schedule of activities. Therefore, this initiative aimed to provide opportunities to participate in music‐making, to increase social interaction and ultimately well‐being in a community environment. Ten music‐making session were scheduled for community‐dwelling people living with dementia and care‐partners, once a month between September 2019 and March 2020. Three sessions did not take place due to Covid19. Eighteen participants consented to take part including seven people living with dementia, five care‐partners and six former care‐partners. Baseline semi‐structured interviews explored the lived experience of music and expectations of the upcoming music‐making cafes. Self‐report questionnaires captured ‘in the moment’ experiences of each music‐making cafe. Follow‐up semi‐structured interviews explored the impact of music‐making on participants' self‐reported well‐being. Interviews were transcribed verbatim and analysed thematically. The findings demonstrate that participating in the music‐making café benefitted the self‐reported well‐being of participants in three ways: first, a sense of camaraderie that enabled the facilitation of connections with others; second, creating opportunities to ‘level the playing field’ by always assuming a person's strengths and abilities; and third, group participation in music‐making meets a need for meaningful musical experiences. We conclude that participating in music‐making is a powerful medium to promote well‐being for community‐dwelling people living with dementia and care‐partners.

30 September 2018 in Dementia
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
SSSarah Kate Smith
Sarah Kate Smith
GMGail A Mountain
Gail A Mountain
RHRebecca J Hawkins
Rebecca J Hawkins
Introduction: Opportunities to participate with enjoyable activities is one of the most frequently reported unmet needs by the person living with dementia. Enabling and intuitive technologies may offer accessible ways to engage with such activities. Objectives: To explore how tablet computers might encourage participation in enjoyable activities by people with moderate levels of dementia and to consider how such technologies might be incorporated into the repertoire of activities currently provided through day care settings. Methods: A focused visual ethnographic approach was developed specifically to meet the research objectives. Twelve participants attending a community day care centre and nine supporters (both volunteers and paid staff) consented to take part in the research. Technology facilitated group activity sessions took place twice a week for a period of four weeks and all were video recorded. Findings: Video analysis demonstrated that the majority of people with dementia found the technology an effective means of participating in enjoyable activities. Analysis also revealed the extent to which participation relies on the existence of effective support. It showed how maintaining focus on retained strengths and abilities enabled the group overall to meet and often exceed their own and others perceived capacity to participate. Finally, analysis confirmed the importance of enjoyment of activities ‘in the moment’ and the need for those supporting people in the moderate stages of dementia to acknowledge and work with this. Conclusion: The use of tablet computers to enhance participation in sociable and enjoyable activities in day care settings is realistic and achievable if supported appropriately.

12 March 2018 in Technologies
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
SSSarah Kate Smith
Sarah Kate Smith
AAArlene J. Astell
Arlene J. Astell
Computer Interactive Reminiscence and Conversation Aid (CIRCA)is an interactive conversation support for people living with dementia. CIRCA facilitates one-to-one conversations and caregiving relationships in formal care environments. Originally developed as a standalone device, a new web-based version of CIRCA has been created to increase availability. The potential of CIRCA to support group activities and conversation between people living with dementia and a facilitator has not previously been explored. The two objectives of this study are (i) to validate the new web-based version of CIRCA against the original standalone device, and (ii) to explore the efficacy of CIRCA in supporting group activity for people with dementia in a formal care setting. This mixed-methods study comprises two parts: (i) an eight-session group activity using the CIRCA stand-alone device, and (ii) an eight-session group activity using the web-based CIRCA. One hundred and eighty people with dementia will be recruited: 90 for part (i) and 90 for part (ii). Measures of cognition and quality of life will be taken at the baseline, post-CIRCA intervention, and three months later, plus video recordings of the group sessions. Both parts of the study will be completed by June 2018. The study will provide evidence on two issues: (i) a validation of the new web-based version of CIRCA, and (ii) the suitability of CIRCA to support group activities in formal care settings for people living with dementia. This protocol is an extended version of the short paper presented at the AAATE 2017 conference and published in Studies in Health Technology & Informatics.