Through their procyclical behavior, loan loss provisions have been determined as one of the factors that contribute to financial instability during a crisis. IFRS 9 was introduced in 2018 with an expected credit loss model replacing the incurred loss model of IAS 39 to mitigate the effect in the future. Our study aims to analyze loan loss provisions of major banks in the Eurozone to determine for the first time if the implementation of IFRS 9, as intended by regulators, has a dampening effect on procyclicality, especially during the stressed situation under COVID‐19. We analyze 51 banks from 12 countries of the European Monetary Union using 2856 firm‐year observations. While no robust evidence of less procyclicality can be found after the implementation of IFRS 9 until the pandemic, we find evidence that loan loss provisions moved countercyclical during 2020, indicating an alleviating effect at the beginning of the exogenous shock.
Endogeneity is a primary concern for empirical research that examines the relationship between firm leadership and company performance. This is especially true for demographic heterogeneity in boardrooms and top management teams, where reverse causalities are prevalent. Based on a systematic literature review, we contribute to the current state of empirical literature by highlighting the effects of mitigating endogeneity methodically, showing how studies differ in various types of demographic heterogeneity variables and endogeneity checks, and how all these influence performance outcomes in research. We thus offer a new perspective on the numerous empirical findings already available. Our findings show that most studies acknowledge and check for endogeneity concerns but do so by employing different methodical approaches. We further show that the utilization of various techniques affects the variability in study outcomes regarding relationship directions. Papers employing more sophisticated methods (e.g., System GMM) have a higher share of positive significant findings than our overall sample. Still, the general trend that an overwhelming share of papers finds at least some significant positive relationship between leadership demographic heterogeneity and financial performance holds firm all the techniques employed. We consider research created from 1990 to 2024 for our sample of 163 publications.
31 December 2021 in International Journal of Innovation and Technology Management