The fetal liver (FL) is the key erythropoietic organ during fetal development, but knowledge on human FL erythropoiesis is very limited. In this study, we sorted primary erythroblasts from FL cells and performed RNA sequencing (RNA-seq) analyses. We found that temporal gene expression patterns reflected changes in function during primary human FL terminal erythropoiesis. Notably, the expression of genes enriched in proteolysis and autophagy was up-regulated in orthochromatic erythroblasts (OrthoEs), suggesting the involvement of these pathways in enucleation. We also performed RNA-seq of in vitro cultured erythroblasts derived from FL CD34+ cells. Comparison of transcriptomes between the primary and cultured erythroblasts revealed significant differences, indicating impacts of the culture system on gene expression. Notably, the expression of lipid metabolism-related genes was increased in cultured erythroblasts. We further immortalized erythroid cell lines from FL and cord blood (CB) CD34+ cells (FL-iEry and CB-iEry, respectively). FL-iEry and CB-iEry were immortalized at the proerythroblast stage and can be induced to differentiate into OrthoEs, but their enucleation ability was very low. Comparison of the transcriptomes between OrthoEs with and without enucleation capability revealed the down-regulation of pathways involved in chromatin organization and mitophagy in OrthoEs without enucleation capacity, indicating that defects in chromatin organization and mitophagy contribute to the inability of OrthoEs to enucleate. Additionally, the expression of HBE1, HBZ, and HBG2 was up-regulated in FL-iEry compared with CB-iEry, and such up-regulation was accompanied by down-regulated expression of BCL11A and up-regulated expression of LIN28B and IGF2BP1. Our study provides new insights into human FL erythropoiesis and rich resources for future studies.

Erythropoiesis occurs first in the yolk sac as a transit “primitive” form, then is gradually replaced by the “definitive” form in the fetal liver (FL) during fetal development and in the bone marrow (BM) postnatally. While it is well known that differences exist between primitive and definitive erythropoiesis, the similarities and differences between FL and BM definitive erythropoiesis have not been studied. Here we performed comprehensive comparisons of erythroid progenitors and precursors at all maturational stages sorted from E16.5 FL and adult BM. We found that FL cells at all maturational stages were larger than their BM counterparts. We further found that FL BFU-E cells divided at a faster rate and underwent more cell divisions than BM BFU-E. Transcriptome comparison revealed that genes with increased expression in FL BFU-Es were enriched in cell division. Interestingly, the expression levels of glucocorticoid receptor Nr3c1, Myc and Myc downstream target Ccna2 were significantly higher in FL BFU-Es, indicating the role of the Nr3c1-Myc-Ccna2 axis in the enhanced proliferation/cell division of FL BFU-E cells. At the CFU-E stage, the expression of genes associated with hemoglobin biosynthesis were much higher in FL CFU-Es, indicating more hemoglobin production. During terminal erythropoiesis, overall temporal patterns in gene expression were conserved between the FL and BM. While biological processes related to translation, the tricarboxylic acid cycle and hypoxia response were upregulated in FL erythroblasts, those related to antiviral signal pathway were upregulated in BM erythroblasts. Our findings uncovered previously unrecognized differences between FL and BM definitive erythropoiesis and provide novel insights into erythropoiesis.

The fetal liver (FL) is the key erythropoietic organ during fetal development, but knowledge on human FL erythropoiesis is very limited. In this study, we sorted primary erythroblasts from FL cells and performed RNA sequencing analyses. We found that temporal gene expression patterns reflected changes in function during primary human FL terminal erythropoiesis. Notably, expression of genes enriched in proteolysis and autophagy was upregulated in orthochromatic erythroblasts (OrthoE), suggesting involvement of these pathways in enucleation. We also performed RNA sequencing of in vitro cultured erythroblasts derived from FL CD34 ⁺ cells. Comparison of transcriptomes between the primary and cultured erythroblasts revealed significant differences, indicating impacts of the culture system on gene expression. Notably, lipid metabolism gene expression was increased in cultured erythroblasts. We further immortalized erythroid cell lines from FL and cord blood (CB) CD34 ⁺ cells (FL-iEry and CB-iEry, respectively). FL-iEry and CB-iEry are immortalized at the proerythroblast stage and can be induced to differentiate into OrthoE, but their enucleation ability is very low. Comparison of transcriptomes between OrthoE with and without enucleation capability revealed downregulation of pathways involved in chromatin organization and mitophagy in OrthoE without enucleation capacity, indicating that defects in chromatin organization and mitophagy contribute to the inability of OrthoE to enucleate. Additionally, the expression levels of HBE1 , HBZ , and HBG2 were upregulated in FL-iEry compared with CB-iEry, and this was accompanied by downregulation of BCL11A and upregulation of LIN28B and IGF2BP1 . Our study provides new insights into human FL erythropoiesis and rich resources for future studies.