This systematic review examines methodological choices in assessing hydrogen production and utilisation technologies using prospective life cycle assessments (LCA) between 2010 and 2022, following PRISMA guidelines. The review analysed 32 peer-reviewed articles identified through Scopus, Web of Science, and BASE. The study reveals a significant gap in the consistent application of prospective LCA methodologies for emerging hydrogen technologies. Most studies employed attributional approaches, often lacking prospective elements in life cycle inventory (LCI) modelling. Although some initiatives to integrate forward-looking components were noted, there was often lack of clarity in defining LCA objectives, technology readiness level (TRL), and upscaling methods. Of the 22 studies that focused on emerging hydrogen technologies, few detailed upscaling methods. Additionally, the review identified common issues, such as the limited use of prospective life cycle impact assessment (LCIA) methods, inadequate data quality evaluation, and insufficient sensitivity and uncertainty analysis. These findings highlight the substantial gaps in modelling low-TRL hydrogen technologies and the need for more robust, comprehensive approaches to assess uncertainties. The review also identified common practices and areas for improvement to enhance the reliability and relevance of hydrogen technology environmental assessments.
Purpose Displacement factors (DFs) quantify climate benefits of wood-based products relative to non-wood alternatives. Existing DFs are typically static, focus on semi-finished materials, and lack harmonized, transparently documented modelling assumptions. Economy-wide decarbonization motivates a forward-looking assessment. Methods This study provides an open-access, unit-process-based database of future-oriented DFs for 81 wood-product-material-variants across six end-use categories. It uses time-explicit life cycle assessment (LCA), which links each process to the technology landscape at the time it occurs, under three decarbonization scenarios for 2020–2070. Results Wood-based products showed positive DFs in 2020, with weighted averages ranging from near-zero for furniture to 1.04 kg C/kg C for chemicals and textiles, though generally lower than previous estimates. DFs declined over time for all products except chemicals, most steeply under climate-ambitious scenarios. Wood sustained the highest benefit in the least ambitious scenario. The DF decline was driven by faster decarbonization of non-wood products, which contain proportionally more fossil-intensive components. Time-explicit LCA yielded lower DFs for long-lived products as end-of-life processes were assigned to more decarbonized future years. Energy-related DFs approached near-zero by 2070. Conclusion The findings support redirecting wood flows from energy toward long-lived material applications and caution against harvest intensification justified on displacement arguments alone.
The transition to a sustainable and resilient European energy system requires robust and transparent methods to assess how emerging clean energy technologies contribute to sustainability, circularity, resilience, and technological autonomy. Although several approaches to assess these dimensions have been proposed, they remain fragmented. This study systematically reviewed and analyzed 217 peer-reviewed articles and reports assessing emerging clean energy technologies following the Reporting Standards for Systematic Evidence Syntheses (ROSES) guidelines. The findings show that environmental and economic dimensions rely on mature approaches such as Life Cycle Assessment (LCA), Life Cycle Costing (LCC), and Techno-Economic Analysis (TEA). Social Life Cycle Assessment (S-LCA) is increasingly used, but harmonized indicators are missing. Circularity, EU resilience, and technological autonomy dimensions remain underdeveloped and inconsistently operationalized. Overall, methodological robustness improves with higher technology maturity, and prospective approaches can enhance comparability and policy relevance. Key methodological gaps persist, including limited transparency, poor data disclosure, and scarce application of uncertainty and sensitivity analyses. The review concludes that to strengthen the assessment of emerging clean energy technologies, methodological frameworks should be transparent and able to adapt to different technological maturity levels. Harmonized indicators, materiality analysis, prospective approaches, and uncertainty management can be implemented more readily, but integrated frameworks will require coordinated methodological advances.