This study analyzed the interactions between efficiency, productivity, and the policy of recyclable materials recovery in municipal solid waste (MSW) services in Brazil, using data from the National Sanitation Information System (SNIS) for 199 MSWs, encompassing a balanced longitudinal panel from 2013 to 2022. In this context, the study employed the dynamic slacks-based measure (DSBM) model to assess the intertemporal efficiency and productivity of MSWs. This model is an additive extension of traditional data envelopment analysis, as it does not focus solely on the overall efficiency of operators. Additionally, multiple correspondence analysis (MCA), multiple independent sample tests, and generalized estimating equations (GEE) were utilized to identify potential interactions among the variables of interest. The main contribution of this study lies in its analysis of dynamic intertemporal efficiency, considering the indirect influence of operating expenses as a carry-over, which impacts the continuity of efficiency across periods. Insights from the results indicated an average efficiency of 61.9% and an accumulated productivity loss over the analyzed period. The recovery of recyclable materials exhibited a negative interaction with both the efficiency of MSW operators performing selective collection and the overall technological advancement of MSW systems. This underscores the importance of integrating this field of study within the circular economy framework and fostering recycling initiatives. Factors such as population density, gross domestic product (GDP), and the COVID-19 pandemic influenced efficiency and, in certain aspects, productivity. The findings provide insights suggesting that policymakers and regulatory agencies should consider these results to enhance eco-efficiency and eco-productivity policies, particularly in alignment with the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) and current Brazilian legislation.
This study analyzed the relevance of governance structure for efficient revenue collection by Brazilian water utilities (WUs). Data were collected from the National Information System on Sanitation (SNIS) for 127 Brazilian WUs, covering a balanced longitudinal panel from 2018 to 2022. The governance structures evaluated included ownership (public or private) and corporatization (publicly traded or not). We searched scientific databases and did not find any studies on the efficiency of specific WUs in collecting customer bills for services rendered and its relationship with this type of governance; thus, this is the main innovative contribution of this study to the literature. In the first stage, this study utilized the dynamic slack-based model (DSBM) to assess revenue collection efficiency. In the second stage, an econometric model with generalized estimating equation (GEE) was used to explain the efficiency. The findings revealed a global average inefficiency in revenue collection of 50.47%. Corporatization was linked to higher collection efficiencies, while ownership type was significantly linked with lower collection efficiency. Factors such as tariff accessibility, urbanization, and the COVID-19 pandemic also influenced efficiency. This study suggests that regulatory bodies should consider these insights to implement policies that prevent inefficiencies from affecting the tariff system for services.