Leveraging Process-Based Models to Improve Index Crop Insurance DesignCrop production is constrained by uncertainty in climate conditions and extreme weather events globally (Afshar et al., 2021). These barriers not only reduce crop yields but also compromise the livelihoods of smallholder farmers, emphasizing the urgent necessity to implement effective risk management strategies (Adelesi et al., 2024). Traditional indemnity-based crop insurance offers compensation based on actual losses, but only after a formal loss assessment has been completed. While this approach provides tailored protection, it often involves delays that can be challenging for those farmers who need timely financial support the most. A potential-though not perfect-alternative is index-based crop insurance (IBCI), which determines payouts differently. Instead of relying on post-loss evaluations, IBCI triggers payments based on predefined indices, such as rainfall levels or temperature thresholds. This allows for faster disbursement of funds, though it may not always perfectly match individual losses, if the index used does not correlate one-to-one with the loss. However, index insurance can mitigate many of the drawbacks of traditional indemnity insurance, offering more transparent, cost-effective risk transfer mechanisms and a rapid loss settlement process (Kapphan et al., 2012). However, a significant challenge in designing IBCI lies in ensuring that the selected index accurately reflects the actual losses experienced by farmers. When there is a mismatch between the index-triggered payout and the farmer's real loss, a problem known as basis risk arises (Afshar et al., 2021). An oftenoverlooked fact about basis risk is that it can be negative, where farmers suffer losses but receive no compensation, or positive, where payouts are made despite no actual loss. Both forms undermine the credibility, efficiency of IBCI, potentially discouraging farmer participation and limiting the insurance's protective value.A potential way to reduce basis risk can be found in process-based crop models, also referred to as crop simulation models. These models offer a powerful avenue for enhancing the design and performance of index crop insurance (Will et al., 2022). While a large body of research exists on index-based insurance design using statistical, econometric, and remote-sensing approaches (Singh and Agrawal, 2019;Abdi et al., 2022;Ghahari et al., 2019), the direct application of process-based crop models in this context remains relatively scarce (Abdi et al., 2022). This gap highlights the novelty and importance of exploring how mechanistic models can contribute to more robust index design and reduced basis risk. These models utilize quantitative descriptions of the physiological and biophysical processes governing crop growth and development, simulating yield responses to various environmental factors and management practices (Will et al., 2022). By providing a mechanistic understanding of crop-environment interactions, process-based models can contribute to the development of more robust and relevant insurance indices, potentially reducing basis risk and improving the overall effectiveness of IBCI schemes (Will et al., 2022). Despite their potential, process-based crop models remain underutilized in developing IBCI. We explore their application in designing IBCI, addressing critical issues such as (1) data requirements, (2) calibration and validation approaches, and (3) spatial and temporal scales. By examining these factors, we identify key challenges and offer guidance to support future research that integrates process-based crop models into index insurance development. Our analysis is restricted to studies that solely applied process-based models to index crop insurance; hybrid models are excluded, although relevant regional examples are referenced to illustrate context.The utility of process-based crop models in agricultural risk assessment and insurance design is fundamentally dependent on the availability and quality of a range of key data inputs (Will et al., 2022). These inputs drive the model simulations and directly influence the accuracy and reliability of their outputs, which subsequently inform the design and pricing of index insurance contracts (Nguyen-Huy et al., 2024). Key data inputs can be primarily grouped into weather data, soil characteristics, crop management practices, and crop phenology.Simulating crop growth responses to atmospheric conditions requires high-resolution, temporally continuous weather data that include daily or sub-daily measurements of temperature (minimum and maximum), precipitation, and solar radiation (Will et al., 2022). Decades of historical weather datasets are necessary for model calibration, validation, and for simulating the range of yield variability under different climatic scenarios, which is important for actuarial assessments in insurance (Kapphan et al., 2012). Yet, spatially dense networks of weather stations may not be available, especially in remote or developing areas, creating a large source of uncertainty in model inputs and outputs (Li et al., 2021a), while the quality and completeness of historical records also affect the strength of the yield data produced by simulation (Nieto et al., 2012); for example, missing rainfall measurements or temperature errors can inaccurately characterize key stages of crop development and stress, resulting in erroneous yields with potentially higher basis risk in derived insurance products (Li et al., 2021a). Recent studies in developing and data-scarce regions demonstrate that supplementing sparse ground observations with satellite or model-based data can significantly enhance process-based model performance and yield simulation reliability (Feleke et al., 2021;Kumara et al., 2023).The availability of water and nutrients for plant growth is one of the main determinants of crop yield and production, which is governed by soil...