In sport games, perceptual–cognitive skills are discussed as a decisive aspect of players’ expertise. However, an understanding of the relationship between these skills and actual game performance is limited, particularly, regarding the role of pattern identification and situational-probability estimation in performance. The present study thus aimed to examine how identification of teammates’ defensive qualities relates to decision-making performance in a 3:3 virtual-reality defensive task. Examining data collected in two previously published studies, we analyzed the relationship between explicit pattern detection and response correctness, and also as a function of players’ experience. Experience was operationalized as either expertise level (Experiment 1) or task-specific experience (Experiment 2). As expected, the explicit detection of a game-specific pattern was found to be facilitated by experience. However, the results imply that it is accumulated experience that enhances decision-making performance rather than the degree of self-generated explicit knowledge. This finding supports the notion of “representational redescription” as introduced by Karmiloff-Smith (1994). For sports practice, this suggests that the pattern identification demonstrated by skilled athletes should not be overestimated as a predictor of game performance, while the explicit provision of knowledge might be beneficial for less-skilled athletes, particularly in situations of high uncertainty.
26 September 2025 in Frontiers in Sports and Active Living
Introduction: Excellent performance in game sports is largely determined by a functional decision-making process which integrates different perceptual-cognitive skills. This paper aims to bridge empirical and practical knowledge by exploring top-level players' subjective experiences in decision making.Methods: A semi-structured interview guide was developed and informed by existing decision-making literature including three categories (i.e., gaze behavior, information integration, and decision determinants). Each Switzerland's most successful male and female player from five different game sports (i.e., beach volleyball, floorball, handball, ice hockey, and soccer) participated in single interviews, focusing different aspects within each of the three categories. Verbal data were analyzed using a deductive thematic analysis after which top-level players' perspective was compared against the selected theoretical concepts and empirical findings.Results: The data analysis showed that top-level players use gaze anchor and foveal spot for peripheral vision, anticipate based on a weighted combination of kinematic and different contextual information, and decide predominantly intuitively by applying if-then automatism.Discussion: The present findings reflect well-examined factors of the decision-making process and uncover specifics relevant to top-level players but underrepresented in the literature such as decisional relevance when using peripheral vision, or tactical strategies influencing decisions. Therefore, our results provide player-perspective information underlying the decision-making process in complex game situations as well as valuable recommendations for applied practices.
In time-pressured decisions, humans exploit contextual knowledge to reduce uncertainty about the unfolding situation and to improve behavioral control. However, in complex real-world settings, it remains unclear whether the explicit provision of contextual information is beneficial or not. We thus examined the information gain of explicitly provided information as a function of expertise, information uncertainty and acquisition phase. To this end, we measured the positioning of female handball players (N = 36 experts + 36 near-experts) in a virtual-reality defensive task as a function of their teammates’ defensive-strength patterns, which was either explicitly instructed or had to be self-generated. Furthermore, the certainty of provided information was experimentally varied (67% vs. 83% consistent information). All eight groups–expertise (2) x acquisition condition (2) x information certainty (2)–improved performance in terms of the positional difference in their defense movements, meaning that they either moved more sideways to support their neighboring teammate or remained more often in their position when no support was required. However, an explicit-knowledge test showed no differences regarding pattern detection between the acquisition conditions, implying that the performance enhancement of the self-generated groups was not due to explicit-knowledge accumulation. Most notably, experts generally benefitted from explicit instructions whereas for near-experts, an information gain could only be revealed for comparably certain information. This interaction implies that future research on explicit provision vs. self-generation of contextual knowledge should pursue a more differential approach, thereby also considering gender and age as well as personality factors.