The present paper argues for a shift in teacher knowledge and beliefs about the role of group work in the teaching and learning of emergent bilingual students. Using case study data from an eighth grade classroom, the authors analyze the role of collaboration in the interaction with grade-level text of emergent bilingual students. The analysis demonstrates that the quality of collaboration mediates in significant ways the opportunities available to emergent bilinguals for both content and language learning. The authors suggest that expanding students’ repertoires of practice to include collaborative learning should be a worthwhile instructional goal in mainstream classrooms. The analysis problematizes the currently dominant view of group work as an instructional strategy, and supports the positioning of collaboration as a key disciplinary practice in the new college and career readiness standards. The article offers a conceptual framework for contrasting different types of collaboration that is based on Engeström's (1993. “Developmental Studies on Work as a Testbench of Activity Theory.” In Understanding Practice: Perspectives on Activity and Context, edited by S. Chaiklin and J. Lave, 64–103. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press) activity theory.
This paper discusses the development of district–university partnerships at the onset of a multi-year grant-funded initiative focused on leadership for equity. Using three illustrative partnership cases, we investigated district–university collaboration through the lens of mutualism, or the mutually beneficial nature of the relationship. Our data analysis revealed the following dynamics as important for the development of mutualism: shared commitment, shared ownership, new collaborative structures, reciprocal benefits, and boundary spanners. We approached partnerships as learning processes, and used a typology of interorganizational learning to understand better how these dynamics sustained the partnerships. Our study contributes to the field’s knowledge of the development of formal partnerships in general as well as of partnerships explicitly focused on equity specifically.
4 April 2025 in Journal of Professional Capital and Community
Purpose: This study explores the emergence of district-university partnerships in the context of a multi-year, grant-funded initiative to promote equity-centered school leadership. The initiative involved eight large urban school districts in the United States and began in 2021. Design/methodology/approach: We use an ecological model and explanatory mixed-methods design to investigate the evolution of collaborative relationships between university and district partners during the first two and a half years of the initiative. Findings: Our analysis of social network survey data illustrates that strong partnerships took two years to emerge. While the number of university partners did not change significantly, they became more central to and integrated in the work. Insights from our qualitative analysis suggest that the growth of collaborative relationships was promoted by shared goals and strategic actions by both the partners and the funding organization. The district and university partners in our study shared a commitment to advancing equity in schools and engaged in mandated as well as voluntary collaboration. Originality/value: Our insights contribute to the knowledge base on how intentional networks can promote alignment between university leader preparation programs and district-specific equity needs and give rise to new collaborative structures and processes that are mutually beneficial to both partners.
Introduction: This paper is a case study of equity-centered continuous improvement that informed school leader professional learning. The work is a collaboration between researchers and district leaders in Columbus City Schools, USA. The continuous improvement process took place in the context of a multi-year, grant-funded initiative aimed at expanding school leaders’ capacity to advance equity in their buildings.Methods: Our findings are based on a thematic analysis of qualitative data that include interviews, field notes, and artifacts.Results: We highlight three social conditions that made the improvement work possible: a district-wide focus on equity, a culture of learning, and partnerships with external organizations. We explore in detail two examples of continuous improvement in the district, both related to school leader professional learning. We shed light on factors that hindered the district-wide use of continuous improvement in the district, including the absence of guidance on continuous improvement and the emerging nature of the collaboration among principal supervisors and coaches across the district.Discussion: This work contributes to the field’s understanding of what equity-focused continuous improvement can look like. Our findings suggest that equity-centered continuous improvement encompasses equity-focused goals that aim to address disparities in students’ school experiences, and equity-focused processes that cultivate trust with school leaders and position them as capable learners and agents of change.