Meanings are felt and lived by the human organism before they are articulated. Following insights from pragmatism and embodied cognition, this paper suggests that there is an ‘appropriate’ relationship between what is meant and was is expressed in words and actions that can be formulated as a hitherto neglected yet crucial validity claim, namely congruity (Stimmigkeit). Congruity is what connects the meaningfulness implicit in living a life with the articulated meanings of symbolic communication. We distinguish between the intertwined aspects of (1) semiotic congruity, the fusion between sensual patterns and semiotic meanings, (2) performative congruity, the freedom and ability to articulate qualitatively experienced meaningfulness, and (3) hermeneutic congruity, the capability of achieving congruence between situational meanings and one’s entire being-in-the-world. The latter presupposes a synthesis of horizontal (biographical and experiental) and vertical (pertaining to the relation between the several strata of cultural meanings) congruity.
This book explores theoretical innovations of classical pragmatism and their relevance to a philosophical theory of religion in our time. It considers the ideas of Charles Sanders Peirce, William James, Josiah Royce, and John Dewey on the subject of religion, with particular emphasis on the pragmatist's sensitivity to the ongoing processes to individualize and naturalize human self-understanding. It discusses pragmatic methodology in the philosophy of religion, James's pragmatism and Edgar Sheffield Brightman's personalism as related reactions to the challenges of naturalism and historicism, James's concept of a “sick soul,” and Dewey's concept of experience. It also explores the challenges of contingency in relation to pragmatist philosophy of religion, along with semiotics as the key tool to conceptualizing the significance of transcendence.