Elena Alina Ontanu

Prof. Elena Alina Ontanu


Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

5Years (2022-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
23 November 2024 in Laws
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
FCFrancesco Contini
Francesco Contini
EOElena Alina Ontanu
Elena Alina Ontanu
MVMarco Velicogna
Marco Velicogna
This paper analyzes the impact of AI systems in the judicial domain, adopting an actor–network theory (ANT) framework and focusing on accountability issues emerging when such technologies are introduced. Considering three different types of AI applications used by judges, this paper explores how introducing non-accountable artifacts into justice systems influences the actor–network configuration and the distribution of accountability between humans and technology. The analysis discusses the actor–network reconfiguration emerging when speech-to-text, legal analytics, and predictive justice technologies are introduced in pre-existing settings and maps out the changes in agency and accountability between judges and AI applications. The EU legal framework and the EU AI Act provide the juridical framework against which the findings are assessed to check the fit of new technological systems with justice system requirements. The findings show the paradox that non-accountable AI can be used without endangering fundamental judicial values when judges can control the system’s outputs, evaluating its correspondence with the inputs. When this requirement is not met, the remedies provided by the EU AI Act fall short in costs or in organizational and technical complexity. The judge becomes the unique subject accountable for the use and outcome of a non-accountable system. This paper suggests that this occurs regardless of whether the technology is AI-based or not. The concrete risks emerging from these findings are that these technological innovations can lead to undue influence on judicial decision making and endanger the fair trial principle.

1 June 2022 in Oñati Socio-Legal Series
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
EOElena Alina Ontanu
Elena Alina Ontanu
Society is increasingly relying on technology for daily business and activities. This is linked to a rapid update in technology use and digitalisation with courts required to consider new forms of in an electronic environment. The global pandemic increased reliance on technology for justice services and accelerated its integration in the handling of claims. This shift has brought with it certain disruptions. The normative framework concerning electronic evidence is fragmented and still underdeveloped. The handling of new forms of evidence clashes with the traditional paper-based formats that are not able to display all the characteristics of electronic documents. The new Taking of Evidence Regulation (Regulation 2020/1783) adds provisions related to this type of evidence, but this is only partly sufficient for completing the legal framework. In analysing the integration of this new type of evidence into legal practice, the work of Canguilhem regarding the normal and pathological is used.

30 May 2023 in Law, Technology and Humans
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
EOElena Alina Ontanu
Elena Alina Ontanu
The COVID-19 pandemic temporarily brought national and cross-border procedures to a standstill. Prior to the pandemic, the use of information and communication technology in court procedures was mostly voluntary and seldom used; although various developments were contemplated, they were slow to be financed and implemented. The pandemic and associated limitations gave digitalisation of procedures, including at the European Union (EU) level, a new impetus and increased authorities’ and professionals’ openness towards technology, including in cross-border judicial cooperation. The measures adopted at the time of writing focus on aspects such as communication between competent national authorities in taking of evidence and service of documents. These are expected to soon be extended to all other EU private international law instruments. In cross-border claims, e-CODEX will be the decentralised information technology system used in this process of facilitating access to justice with digital support. The aim is for identification and certifications of e-signatures and e-identities in this digital environment to be based on the eIDAS Regulation. While all these are welcome developments for facilitating and speeding up access to justice, this paper points out that the process still requires some years for its full implementation and may be exposed to various risks, complexities and challenges. Consequently, the process will not put an end to the EU fragmentation but will work around national and EU realities.

28 November 2025 in Tilburg Law Review
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
EOElena Alina Ontanu
Elena Alina Ontanu
ETEric Tjong Tjin Tai
Eric Tjong Tjin Tai
Dispute resolution in the hands of courts has long been criticised as problematic. Digital technology and innovation are changing dispute resolution, and this has an impact on procedural justice. This paper scrutinises how technology (tech) is responding to the criticism of traditional court proceedings (e.g. complexity, high costs) and the new challenges tech brings with it. The analysis looks at five key tech interventions: the digitisation of civil procedures, digital procedural tools, platform-based online dispute resolution (ODR), blockchain-enabled ODR, and the emerging use of artificial intelligence in decision-making. For each proposed tech development, the analysis considers the potential advantages they bring to tackle traditional justice problems as improved access, cost reduction, and speed of proceedings, as well as new criticisms, such as reduced transparency, hidden influences, insufficient or overfiltering, diminished opportunities for in-person hearings, and the risk of reinforcing power imbalances. Framing the discussion within the context of procedural justice, drawing on Art. 6 ECHR standards and social science perspectives on what parties are looking for in dispute procedures, the paper argues for a flexible access to justice approach and system-wide ‘geography of justice’. This framework envisions a pluralistic dispute resolution landscape that carefully balances technological efficiency with the imperative to uphold fundamental rights and ensure fair outcomes for parties.

15 June 2024
Verified
Book Chapter
Closed access
PDF file
EOElena Alina Ontanu
Elena Alina Ontanu

10 June 2024 in International Journal for Court Administration
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
MFMarco Fabri
Marco Fabri
AWAnne Wallace
Anne Wallace
CECaroline Expert-Foulquier
Caroline Expert-Foulquier
SBSimone Benvenuti
Simone Benvenuti
EOElena Alina Ontanu
Elena Alina Ontanu
ATAlexandra Tsvetkova
Alexandra Tsvetkova