High-performance MEMS accelerometers are essential for extreme-environment applications including deep-space exploration and transient-shock monitoring. Conventional semiconductor materials can exhibit structural failure, thermal drift, and parasitic-mode interference under overload. This study presents the design, simulation, and structural optimization of a single-crystal-diamond (SCD) MEMS accelerometer. A multiphysics finite-element framework compares Si, GaAs, SiC, and SCD in linear dynamic range, thermal stability, modal behavior, thermoelastic frequency stability, and mechanical survivability.To suppress out-of-plane modal competition in thin architectures, a one-step global-thickening strategy advanced the X-axis working mode to first order and increased the fundamental resonant frequency to 32.22 kHz. Temperature-dependent eigenfrequency calculations show an SCD thermal frequency coefficient of about -6 ppm/°C from -40 to 120 °C, markedly lower than those of Si, GaAs, and SiC. Direct electromechanical simulations show negligible sensing-channel displacement under Y-axis excitation, whereas out-of-plane Z-axis motion produces appreciable capacitance drift, demonstrating the need for modal purification from a readout perspective. Fabrication-tolerance sweeps indicate that thickness perturbations preserve the intended first-order working mode, while spring-width and proof-mass-length deviations can reorder low-order modes.Leveraging diamond's high specific stiffness and fracture strength, the optimized device achieves a ±800 g linear dynamic range, a quality factor of 6761, and a safety factor of 6.84 under 10,000 g shock. These results establish SCD as a promising structural material for high-frequency, high-stability MEMS accelerometers operating in extreme environments.