Landscape character assessment (LCA) is a crucial tool for conserving an area’s unique character. However, in our literature review, we found no data linking LCA to historic coal mining settings. This systematic review explores the ways in which the landscape character assessment (LCA) methodology has been applied, as well as the factors that influence it, in the conservation of historic coal mine landscapes. It focuses on three areas: analyzing the ways in which LCA has been applied in landscape conservation, proposing recommendations for the application of LCA in historic coal mine setting landscapes, and summarizing the factors that influence LCA in landscape conservation in historic coal mine settings. Methods: This study used the Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) method to perform the systematic review. The whole review was selected from 2030 potential articles; a total of 21 articles were included. Results: This study demonstrates that the LCA approach can be operationalized in the conservation of environmental landscapes in historic coal mines by combining cluster analysis and multi-scale assessment and incorporating other theories. The quality of the results can be affected by factors such as the accuracy and completeness of the data and the complexity and tractability of the model. Conclusions: Future research should focus on improving the data capture technology, model complexity, and design of actionable models. Additionally, we recommend the strategies of enhancing stakeholder engagement and raising public awareness.
Responding to this crisis, the Chinese government has undertaken the initiative to conserve and revitalise the urban historic districts in recent years. However, it has been observed that the process of historical heritage conservation in China is significantly influenced by the top-down protection system that renders the heritage voiceless. Past studies have explored the context of urban heritage conservation based on morphological integrity alone. This necessitates examining the context of the conservation of historic districts from a micro perspective involving human behaviour activities and experiences. This article aimed to navigate the path of urban heritage conservation in historic districts of China from a micro perspective of reviewing the regional cultural experiences. To do so, this article focused on the case of the historic district in Dalian City in China particularly Zhongshan District which is known for Zhongshan Square surrounded by classical buildings built in the early 20th century. Following the field visit and qualitative interviews with the residents, the collected data in the form of transcribed responses was thematically analysed. This article presents the main themes identified from the thematic coding of the collected data. The findings from the interviews indicated that the residents were dissatisfied with the heritage conservation interventions implemented by the government. This article concludes that the dissatisfaction among the residents was attributed to the concerns of the residents about the lack of connection between heritage buildings and the urban textures of their surroundings and the lack of supportive policies. This calls for strategic measures driven by regional cultural experiences.
With the transformation of resource-based cities and the restructuring of industrial sectors, the sustainable conservation of coal mining heritage has become a global focus. In China, coal mining heritage faces challenges such as degradation and inadequate management, highlighting the urgent need for more context-sensitive and systematic conservation approaches. This study develops an integrated, landscape-oriented analytical framework for stakeholder identification to address these challenges and to better understand stakeholder differentiation in coal mining heritage conservation. The research objectives are as follows: (1) to bring together a three-dimensional framework based on material-technical, socio-cultural, and experiential dimensions; (2) to analyse the roles and interactions of stakeholders; and (3) to explore how technical knowledge, socio-cultural memory, and daily experiences influence the protection and reuse of coal mining heritage sites. The study integrates the theoretical frameworks of landscape character assessment, historic urban landscape, and experiential landscape, using data from field observations and interviews analysed via ATLAS.ti. The findings show that the proposed framework offers a more systematic understanding of the dynamic relationships between stakeholders and heritage landscapes, thereby providing practical guidance for local governments and relevant institutions in developing inclusive and context-sensitive conservation strategies.