Background: The push towards commercialization is driven by the modernization paradigm which argues that traditional subsistence farming is backward and primitive. Despite commercialization having the potential to enhance people’s livelihoods, it can also bring unfathomable social differentiation and widen inequalities in communities. This paper investigates the gendered decision-making and expenditure choices of smallholder households in the context of agricultural commercialization in Central Malawi. Methods: The analysis is performed by employing sequential mixed methods of quantitative and qualitative data collection, consisting of 28 focus group discussions, 100 life histories, and 519 surveys. Qualitative data were analysed using thematic content analysis while quantitative data were analyzed using descriptive and various regression estimations. Results: The results show that many men heads make decisions on cultivated plots and control realized income. The results further show that there are no differences between households headed by women and those headed by men in pursuit of markets. Women’s participation in markets is limited by lack of means of production. Men are getting more involved in crops that were dominated by women such as groundnuts. Women plot managers engaged more with markets, but their control of realized income was less associated with reinvesting in crop commercialization which is also reflected in their expenditure choices. When they control income, women spend relatively less than men on both productive and households assets. In households headed by men, the men dominate selling of produce, decisions on the control over resources, income, and expenditure choices, which results in deepening gender inequalities. Conclusions: Differences exist in expenditure choices between women and men which points to differing priorities and disparities in access to productive resources. Men dominate decision-making which is preferred by some women to maintain intrahousehold harmony. There is need to create targeted programs for diverse groups of women through participatory approaches to address strategic needs. Women unable to farm due to lack of means of production need social protection programs. Women without decision-making power require empowerment initiatives and gender dialogue sessions to foster joint household activities. Commercial based interventions should go beyond mere targeting of women and men but embed equality interventions to avoid deepening social inequalities.
This paper examines the determinants of livelihood trajectories of households surveyed in rural Malawi in 2007 that were tracked in 2018. Using a set of indicators, including income source diversification and participation in social assistance programmes, households were placed in different trajectories, namely, dropping out, stepping up, hanging in and stepping in. A multinomial logit model was used to analyse factors explaining placement in a livelihood trajectory. We find that the explanatory factors are not the same for farmers in different pathways. The stepping-up of households is likely with increasing commercialization and significant asset accumulation. Furthermore, the stepping-in trajectory is constrained by initial land holding sizes but is more likely if a household has had experience with the cultivation of several different kinds of crops. We find that crop diversification reduces the chance of dropping out but also increases the possibility of hanging in, implying that the blanket recommendation to farmers to diversify crop production may not attain the same benefits to all farmers. This may well be complemented with useful extension services, especially for young farming households. Overall, the study findings point to the complexity and the need for context-dependent development approaches to provide sustainable escapes from poverty.
15 January 2025 in South African Journal of Agricultural Extension (SAJAE)
Market-oriented extension and advisory services enable linkages among actors within agricultural value chains, which is necessary for commercialisation. The study analysed the market orientation of extension approaches employed by various service providers. Qualitative methods were used to collect data from 12 key informants and 84 farmers through 11 focus group discussions. The study targeted extension providers from public and private sectors and non-governmental and farmer-based organisations. We found that extension service providers employ the commodity specialised approach, farmer business school, project approach and smallholder horticultural empowerment and promotion approaches to reach farmers. There are differences in the market-orientation rating of the approaches. Unlike other service providers, public service providers perceived capacity gaps in all areas. The main challenges faced include inadequate funding, high extension worker-to-farmer ratio, poor policy environment and weak legal frameworks, lack of trust and information sharing among actors, poor coordination among extension service providers and actors, and high illiteracy levels among farmers. We conclude that most approaches are not fully market-oriented. Service providers of extension and advisory services should design and implement tailored market-oriented extension and advisory services for farmers commercialising to different levels.
The study was carried out to assess information needs and access to information communication media among male and female fish farmers in southern Malawi. Specifically, the study investigated the socioeconomic characteristics of fish farmers, the degree of their information needs, and their access to information communication media (ICM), differentiated by gender, age, and literacy levels. A checklist was used to collect data in focus groups and key informant interviews, while a semi-structured questionnaire was employed to collect data from a proportionally random sample of 178 households in a household survey. Qualitative data were analysed using content analysis, while quantitative data were analysed using frequencies, percentages, t-tests, and logistic regression. Fish farmers had information gaps regarding pest and disease management, farm feed formulation, and pond site selection and preparation, regardless of gender, age, or literacy level. The most widely available ICMs among the fish farmers were mobile phones and radios. Gender, literacy levels, age and group membership significantly influenced fish farmers' access to ICM. It was recommended that extension agents intensify their efforts to contact fish farmers and disseminate useful information to them via mobile phones, while considering gender considerations in the use of the ICM.