Statistical graphics are a fundamental, yet often overlooked, set of components in the repertoire of data analytic tools. Graphs are quick and efficient, yet simple instruments for preliminary exploration of a dataset to understand its structure and to provide insight into influential aspects of inference such as departures from assumptions and latent patterns. In this article, we present and assess a graphical device for choosing a method for estimating population size in capture–recapture studies of closed populations. The basic concept is derived from a homogeneous Poisson distribution where the ratios of neighboring Poisson probabilities multiplied by the value of the larger neighbor count are constant. This property extends to the zero-truncated Poisson distribution, which is of fundamental importance in capture–recapture studies. In practice, however, this distributional property is often violated. The graphical device developed here, the ratio plot, can be used for assessing specific departures from a Poisson distribution. For example, simple contaminations of an otherwise homogeneous Poisson model can be easily detected and a robust estimator for the population size can be suggested. Several robust estimators are developed and a simulation study is provided to give some guidance on which one should be used in practice. More systematic departures can also easily be detected using the ratio plot. In this article, the focus is on Gamma-mixtures of the Poisson distribution that leads to a linear pattern (called structured heterogeneity) in the ratio plot. More generally, the article shows that the ratio plot is monotone for arbitrary mixtures of power series densities. This article has online supplementary materials.
In 2013, Thailand was ranked second in the world in road accident fatalities (RAFs), with 36.2 per 100,000 people. During the Songkran festival, which takes place during the traditional Thai New Year in April, the number of road traffic accidents (RTAs) and RAFs are markedly higher than on regular days, but few studies have investigated this issue as an effect of festivity. This study investigated the factors that contribute to RAFs using various count regression models. Data on 20,229 accidents in 2015 were collected from the Department of Disaster Prevention and Mitigation in Thailand. The Poisson and Conway–Maxwell–Poisson (CMP) distributions, and their zero-Inflated (ZI) versions were applied to fit the data. The results showed that RAFs in Thailand follow a count distribution with underdispersion and excessive zeros, which is rare. The ZICMP model marginally outperformed the CMP model, suggesting that having many zeros does not necessarily mean that the ZI model is required. The model choice depends on the question of interest, and a separate set of predictors highlights the distinct aspects of the data. Using ZICMP, road, weather, and environmental factors affected the differences in RAFs among all accidents, whereas month distinguished actual non-fatal accidents and crashes with or without deaths. As expected, actual non-fatal accidents were 2.37 times higher in April than in January. Using CMP, these variables were significant predictors of zeros and frequent deaths in each accident. The RAF average was surprisingly higher in other months than in January, except for April, which was unexpectedly lower. Thai authorities have invested considerable effort and resources to improve road safety during festival weeks to no avail. However, our study results indicate that people’s risk perceptions and public awareness of RAFs are misleading. Therefore, nationwide road safety should instead be advocated by the authorities to raise society’s awareness of everyday personal safety and the safety of others.
Contact-tracing is one of the most effective tools in infectious disease outbreak control. A capture–recapture approach based upon ratio regression is suggested to estimate the completeness of case detection. Ratio regression has been recently developed as flexible tool for count data modeling and has proved to be successful in the capture–recapture setting. The methodology is applied here to Covid-19 contact tracing data from Thailand. A simple weighted straight line approach is used which includes the Poisson and geometric distribution as special cases. For the case study data of contact tracing for Thailand, a completeness of 83% could be found with a 95% confidence interval of 74%–93%.
Background: We investigate the completeness of contact tracing for COVID-19 during the first wave of the COVID-19 pandemic in Thailand, from early January 2020 to 30 June 2020. Methods: Uni-list capture-recapture models were applied to the frequency distributions of index cases to inform two questions: (1) the unobserved number of index cases with contacts, and (2) the unobserved number of index cases with secondary cases among their contacts. Results: Generalized linear models (using Poisson and logistic families) did not return any significant predictor (age, sex, nationality, number of contacts per case) on the risk of transmission and hence capture-recapture models did not adjust for observed heterogeneity. Best fitting models, a zero truncated negative binomial for question 1 and zero-truncated Poisson for question 2, returned sensitivity estimates for contact tracing performance of 77.6% (95% CI = 73.75–81.54%) and 67.6% (95% CI = 53.84–81.38%), respectively. A zero-inflated negative binomial model on the distribution of index cases with secondary cases allowed the estimation of the effective reproduction number at 0.14 (95% CI = 0.09–0.22), and the overdispersion parameter at 0.1. Conclusion: Completeness of COVID-19 contact tracing in Thailand during the first wave appeared moderate, with around 67% of infectious transmission chains detected. Overdispersion was present suggesting that most of the index cases did not result in infectious transmission chains and the majority of transmission events stemmed from a small proportion of index cases.
29 September 2026 in Statistical Methods in Medical Research
Dual system estimation is a statistical tool used to estimate the hidden population where each of the two sources covers part of the population. In estimation, the widely used Lincoln–Petersen and Chapman estimators are used under the assumption of two-source independence. However, this situation is often unrealistic, and the traditional estimators might have a large bias, especially if the two sources experience a large dependence. To improve the methodology, covariate information is used for stratification. We formulate the strata-adjusted Chapman estimator for estimating the population size. Furthermore, the log-linear modeling approach is adopted to cope with covariate information. Two semi-parametric (imputed) bootstrap methods using the log-linear model with and without incorporating the model selection procedure are proposed to quantify the uncertainty surrounding the estimates of the unknown population size. Across all designs, methods that exploit covariate information—either via stratification or within the log-linear modeling framework—consistently reduce bias and mean squared error relative to unadjusted estimators that ignore heterogeneity. For interval estimation, the imputed bootstrap that incorporates model selection in each replicate achieves coverage close to the nominal level across heterogeneous and sparse regimes, typically outperforming both the fixed-model bootstrap and normal-theory intervals for the strata-adjusted Chapman. We illustrate these approaches in an application to estimate the hidden number of suicides in Cambodia and heroin users in Thailand.
Background Thailand was rank second in the world in 2013 on the road accident fatality (RAF) rate, killing 36.2 of every 100,000 Thai peoples. In the past decade, during Songkran festival, the traditional Thai new year, the number of road traffic accidents (RTAs) was markedly higher than normal day life, but few studies have yet investigated this issue as the effect of festivity. The objective of this study was to investigate factors contributing to RAF using various count regression models. Methods Data of 20,229 accidents in 2015 were collected from the Department of Disaster Prevention and Mitigation, Thailand. Poisson, Conway–Maxwell–Poisson, and their Zero-Inflated versions were applied to analyze factors associated with the number of fatalities in an accident. Results The RAFs in Thailand follow a count distribution with underdispersion and excessive zeros which is rare. The best fitting model, the ZICMP regression model returns significant predictors (road characteristics, weather conditions, environmental conditions, and month) on the number of fatalities in an accident. The model consists of the count part encapsulating both non-excess zeros and death counts and the zero-part representing the considerable number of zeros during the festival months. The estimated proportion of the zero-part is 0.275 accounting for 5,563 non-fatal accidents. More specifically, the excessive number of no deaths can be explained by the month factor. The mean number of fatalities was lower in the festive periods than other months, with the highest in November. Conclusion For long, Thai authorities have put a lot of efforts and resources into improving road safety over the festival weeks, often they failed. This study indicates that people’s risk perception and public awareness of RAFs are mislead. Instead, nationwide road safety should have been announced by the authorities to raise the awareness of society towards everyday personal safety and the safety of others.