The phenomenon of child abuse/maltreatment is underestimated and often represents a difficult challenge for healthcare professionals and forensic pathologists who must proceed with the differential diagnosis with accidental or self-induced events, or with lesions due to pathologies that overlap with that of mistreatment, defined as “Mimics”. This study presents a case series with the aim of discussing lesions that may mimic signs of physical abuse in children but are due to a different etiology to raise awareness and train healthcare professionals and forensic pathologists on possible confounding factors in order to avoid diagnostic errors. Six cases of “Mimics” out of 418 cases of suspected mistreatment (1.43% of cases) were identified, presenting skin lesions initially classified as injuries of abuse due to their location and type and, in particular, sexual abuse for three cases. Then, the lesions and the subjects, in particular the anamnestic history, were examined by a multidisciplinary team and the diagnosis of genital lichen sclerosus et atrophicus in three cases, and the results of popular healing techniques (i.e., “cupping”) in the other three cases were ascertained. These situations require specific skills and a forensic background from healthcare professionals to conduct a correct differential diagnosis and the intervention of a multidisciplinary team to investigate every possible pathology or alternative therapeutic practice that could simulate child abuse. In particular, when “mimics” are due to alternative medicine, it should not strictly be considered child abuse, but professionals must be aware of the hypothesis of mistreatment in case of non-medical indication or potential personal injuries from other crimes, such as illegal practice of the medicine. This awareness is also crucial to direct the child toward appropriate medical care, and it is essential to recognize that these conditions can coexist within the same clinical presentation.

Infantile occult exposure to cocaine in domestic environments represents a complex clinical and medico-legal problem, which can be associated with abuse and neglect and with potential short- and long-term health risks for children. The authors present a retrospective study on 764 children under 14 years old who accessed the Emergency Department of IRCCS Meyer from 2016 to 2023 and were included in the GAIA (Child and Adolescent Abuse Group) protocol for suspected maltreatment and abuse, and for which a urine toxicology analysis was performed. The aim is to discuss the medico-legal implications and highlight the need for a thorough evaluation and management of such situations. Urine screening tests for substances of abuse (e.g., cocaine, opiates, etc.) were performed with an EMIT^® Siemens VIVA-E drug testing system (Siemens, Newark DE) in 124 cases for which the child’s clinical condition raised suspicion of intoxication, or the family context indicated distress or substance abuse dependency. The screening results revealed the presence of cocaine and its main metabolite, benzoylecgonine, in the urine of 11 children. In one case, a single girl was brought to the Emergency Department by staff from the facility where she and her mother were staying. In most of the cases, children were brought to the Emergency Department by their parents who accessed the Emergency Department due to various clinical manifestations (drowsiness, agitation, seizures, hypotonia, diarrhea, vomiting, etc.), except for one case of eye trauma suspected to be caused by abuse or neglect by one of the parents. Three of the children did not have signs or symptoms attributable to substance exposure, whilst eight of the cases presented some of the symptoms associated with occult infant exposure to cocaine, such as neurological manifestations, seizures, gastrointestinal symptoms, and respiratory depression. The probable mode of intake was mostly through breastfeeding and continuous environmental exposure due to domestic contamination or inhalation of “crack”. In the case of a 12-hour-old infant, there was probable prenatal in utero exposure. All the children were hospitalized, some for medical reasons and others solely as a precautionary measure for proper care. In all cases, a report was made to the Prosecutors as required by the Italian Penal Code, as well as to the Court of Minor. The study highlighted the importance of a multidisciplinary approach involving pediatricians, social workers, and forensics, as well as close collaboration with the relevant authorities, as the Gaia service at IRCCS Meyer offers. The occasional detection of cocaine in cases that showed no suspicion of intoxication led to a modification of the procedure and the development of a standardized protocol at IRCCS Meyer both in terms of prevention and in the detection and interception of hidden cases, in order to intervene early and initiate the necessary care pathways (secondary prevention). This protocol includes routine toxicological urine testing in all suspected or confirmed cases of child abuse, not just in those where symptoms might suggest a suspicion of intoxication.

Background: Medical child abuse (MCA), previously known as Münchausen syndrome by proxy, involves the fabrication or induction of illness by caregivers—most commonly the mother—leading to unnecessary medical interventions and potential harm to the child. Methods: This retrospective study analyzed cases of suspected or confirmed MCA managed by the GAIA multidisciplinary team at Meyer Children’s Hospital, Florence, between 2010 and 2022. Cases were identified using Rosenberg diagnostic criteria and red flags outlined by the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) and the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health (RCPCH). Data were extracted from medical records and analyzed descriptively. Results: Among 816 cases of child maltreatment, 8 (0.99%) were identified as MCA. The median age of affected children was 5 years (range: 4–12 years), with a female predominance (6/8, 75%). All perpetrators were biological mothers (8/8, 100%). Children had a median of 23 emergency department visits (range: 4–44), with the most frequent presentations being fever (6/8, 75%), minor trauma (7/8, 87.5%), respiratory complaints (5/8, 62.5%), and gastrointestinal symptoms (4/8, 50%). According to Rosenberg criteria, 5 cases (62.5%) were classified as “possible diagnosis,” 1 (12.5%) as “definitive diagnosis,” 1 (12.5%) as “diagnosis by exclusion,” and 1 (12.5%) as “inconclusive.” Conclusions: Despite its low prevalence, MCA poses serious clinical and ethical challenges. Early detection requires thorough documentation, interdisciplinary collaboration, and improved access to shared medical records. The GAIA model offers a replicable framework for effective multidisciplinary management.