This paper presents a comprehensive review of research on Historic Building Information Modeling (HBIM), focusing on its role as a tool for managing knowledge and supporting conservation practices of Architectural Heritage. While previous review articles and most research works have predominantly addressed geometric modeling—given its significant challenges in the context of historic buildings—this study places greater emphasis on the integration of non-geometric data within the BIM environment. A systematic search was conducted in the Scopus database to extract the 451 relevant publications analyzed in this review, covering the period from 2008 to mid-2024. A bibliometric analysis was first performed to identify trends in publication types, geographic distribution, research focuses, and software usage. The main body of the review then explores three core themes in the development of the information system: the definition of model entities, both semantic and geometric; the data enrichment phase, incorporating historical, diagnostic, monitoring and conservation-related information; and finally, data use and sharing, including on-site applications and interoperability. For each topic, the review highlights and discusses the principal approaches documented in the literature, critically evaluating the advantages and limitations of different information management methods with respect to the distinctive features of the building under analysis and the specific objectives of the information model.
3 October 2025 in The International Archives of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences
This study presents a methodological framework for classifying and interpreting structural damage in masonry buildings through a Historic Building Information Modelling (HBIM) approach, with a particular emphasis on diagnosing crack patterns in domes. The approach was tested on the Dome of Santa Maria del Fiore in Florence (Italy). The first step involves identifying key parameters for systematically describing cracks within the HBIM environment, focusing on their morphology, position, and related deformation. A Diagnostic Support Tool was developed to semi-automate the identification of failure mechanisms, while final interpretation – particularly of contributing causes – remains reliant on expert judgment. The geometric model of the case study was developed and two levels of crack representation – realistic and simplified – were implemented to ensure both interpretative clarity and interoperability with structural analysis software. The Santa Maria del Fiore case study demonstrates the effectiveness of the protocol in capturing the complex behaviour of masonry domes, offering a replicable workflow. The HBIM model was then enriched with data acquired from the structural monitoring system installed on the Dome, one of the most comprehensive ever installed on a historical monument. This integration enabled 3D visualization of crack evolution over time. Key indicators for monitoring data reliability and damage evolution are proposed and applied to the case study.
The Sorrento Peninsula is characterized by a significant occurrence of examples of vernacular architecture, which exhibit distinctive morphological and constructive features. These have been the subject of numerous studies. However, some buildings have undergone a process of transformation over time, the details of which have yet to be investigated. Architectures that initially held a rural character were enlarged and ennobled, thereby becoming what could be termed as “villas of delights”. However, these clearly manifest their origin based on the permanence of some vernacular features. This paper focuses on the analysis of a case study, Villa Murat, which is exemplary in illustrating this process. This thorough interdisciplinary research combines historical investigation, based mainly on archival documents, with a direct examination of the Villa. This has enabled the retracing of the building’s evolution and of the events that occurred in it. An integrated survey, which employed photogrammetry and laser scanning, enabled the assessment of the current state of conservation. The ultimate objective of this research is to propose conservative interventions which, in conjunction with the suggested new intended use, could ensure the preservation of the Villa.
Cultural heritage includes a large variety of historical masonry constructions. The identification of their structural behaviour is challenging due to the complexities of the masonry constructions and the evolution of multiple phases of construction. Advanced tools for geometric surveying and structural analysis can facilitate the preservation of the cultural heritage but transferring data between these tools remains an issue. In this chapter, we propose a critical discussion on the integration between informative models and digital twins by underling open issues e future perspectives.
Rodrigo Gil de Hontañón’s treatise represents a remarkable codification of the empirical scientia underlying late Gothic church design, providing geometric-proportional and construction rules. Although these design criteria have been extensively investigated from a historical perspective, they have only rarely been verified through a systematic comparison with buildings designed by Rodrigo Gil himself, nor have such structures been analyzed using contemporary methods for structural assessment. This paper addresses these issues through the study of the Church of San Miguel in Segovia, designed by Rodrigo Gil, combining historical and geometric investigation, and structural analysis. The geometric-proportional rules described in the treatise are first reconstructed and compared with the geometry derived from laser scanner and photogrammetric surveys, allowing the ideal design geometry to be distinguished from construction adaptations and subsequent deformations. The comparison reveals a remarkable correspondence between the proportional system described in the treatise and the surveyed geometry of the church, confirming the application of Rodrigo Gil’s design principles. The main ribbed vault is then investigated through membrane equilibrium analysis and thrust-line analysis of the tiercerons, showing that the reconstructed geometry is consistent with mechanically admissible equilibrium configurations, and therefore demonstrating that these empirical rules reflected a coherent structural conception rather than merely formal geometric prescriptions. Beyond the specific case of San Miguel, the study demonstrates how the integration of historical treatises, digital survey and structural analysis can contribute to interpreting the scientia underlying late Gothic masonry design.