Virtual reality is considered to be useful in improving procedural skills in dental education, but systems using wearable devices such as head-mounted displays (HMDs) have many problems in terms of long-term use and hygiene, and the accuracy of stereoscopic viewing at close ranges is inadequate. We developed an abutment tooth formation simulator that utilizes a display (spatial reality display—SRD) to precisely reproduce 3D space with naked-eye stereoscopic viewing at close range. The purpose of this was to develop and validate the usefulness of an abutment tooth formation simulator using an SRD. A 3D-CG (three-dimensional computer graphics) dental model that can be cut in real time was output to the SRD, and an automatic quantitative scoring function was also implemented by comparing the cutting results with exemplars. Dentists in the department of fixed prosthodontics performed cutting operations on both a 2D display-based simulator and an SRD-based simulator and conducted a 5-point rating feedback survey. Compared to the simulator that used a 2D display, the measurements of the simulator using an SRD were significantly more accurate. The SRD-based abutment tooth formation simulator received a positive technical evaluation and high dentist satisfaction (4.37), suggesting its usefulness and raising expectations regarding its future application in dental education.