Staphylococcus aureus (S. aureus) is a prominent Gram-positive bacterial pathogen that expresses numerous cytotoxins known to target human polymorphonuclear leukocytes (PMNs or neutrophils). These include leukocidin G/H (LukGH, also known as LukAB), the Panton–Valentine leukocidin (PVL), γ-hemolysin A/B (HlgAB), γ-hemolysin B/C (HlgBC), leukocidin E/D (LukED), α-hemolysin (Hla), and the phenol-soluble modulin-α peptides (PSMα). However, the relative contribution of each of these cytotoxins in causing human PMN lysis is not clear. In this study, we used a library of cytotoxin deletion mutants in the clinically relevant methicillin-resistant S. aureus (MRSA) isolate LAC (strain ST8:USA300) to determine the relative importance of each for causing human PMN lysis upon exposure to extracellular components as well as following phagocytosis. Using flow cytometry to examine plasma membrane permeability and assays quantifying lactose dehydrogenase release, we found that PVL was the dominant extracellular factor causing human PMN lysis produced by USA300. In contrast, LukGH was the most important cytotoxin causing human PMN lysis immediately following phagocytosis with contributions from the other bicomponent leukocidins only observed at later time points. These results not only clarify the relative importance of different USA300 cytotoxins for causing human PMN destruction but also demonstrate how two apparently redundant virulence factors play distinctive roles in promoting S. aureus pathogenesis.