Upon return to campus after the pandemic, students were subjected to receiving lectures online, in class, or by the emerging hybrid approaches. This study reports students’ preference over the three approaches based on the experience gained during the 2022/23 academic session. The study aimed to understand the post-pandemic considerations/factors likely to influence students’ preferences for or against any of the three modes (based on their experiences with each), and implications for developing university sustainability frameworks in the post-pandemic era. One hundred and twenty-seven (127) on-campus Education students in one public university in Malaysia participated in the study. Data were collected through an online forum and interviews with the participants. The data collected were analyzed using content and thematic analysis. Preference for the hybrid approach emerged as a key finding for this study. Additionally, a perceived lack of Faculty engagement and support in the online learning environment, and on-campus learner-environment challenges were identified as factors contributing to the decreased popularity of the online-only class option in the post-pandemic era. Conversely, students’ engagement through faculty presence and technology innovation in class and online emerged as factors that made the hybrid approach the most popular. What the students valued the most in the hybrid approach is the face-to-face interaction that is retained, and the in-class faculty’s innovative use of technology in content delivery, which they believed made learning more effective and interesting in class than online. These findings imply that institutions should prioritize technology integration into face-to-face instruction, leveraging innovative approaches to enhance student engagement and sustainable learning outcomes.
This article problematises the media used for delivery of curriculum at the onset of lockdowns due to the outbreak of the Covid-19 pandemic, which resulted in a sudden cessation of all face-to-face teaching and learning at a South African university. The article reports on how the otherwise neutral WhatsApp social media platform was appropriated to become a serious teaching tool for mathematics and science pre-service teacher educators. The study draws predominantly on connectivism learning theory to understand how WhatsApp was used to continue the teaching of mathematics and science during the Covid-19 lockdowns. The sample consisted of 10 mathematics and science teacher educators from whom data were collected through authentic conversations and questionnaires. The article reports on the affordances and constraints the WhatsApp platform presented, as well as how it reshaped the teaching of mathematics and science. Findings indicate that teacher educators transformed the use of WhatsApp from a social media tool to a tool for supporting teaching. However, being a social tool, WhatsApp does have affordances and constraints when used for teaching. The affordances include ease of access and ease of use, while constraints include the risk of students not possessing smartphones and intrusion into the personal lives of teacher educators.
4 May 2022 in African Journal of Research in Mathematics, Science and Technology Education
This paper contributes to research in responsive teaching in a context of collaborative discussion using video stimulated recall (VSR) techniques. The aim was to gain deeper understanding of the kinds of teachers’ reflective awareness that prompts changes (or lack of change) in responsive primary mathematics teaching. Using a case study methodology, I analysed the VSR interviews of two teachers who demonstrated different patterns of changes in responsive teaching. The findings revealed two distinct and complementary forms of evidence of states of awareness and reflections that support change in responsive teaching practices: (a) teachers acknowledging limitations of their practice; and (b) teachers expanding repertoires of tasks and example spaces. These two forms of evidence provide insights into ways of supporting primary mathematics teaching in the context of VSR techniques. The implication of these findings is that for effective use of VSR interviews, attention should be geared towards getting a teacher to acknowledge the limitations of her practice, and through reflection-oriented questions to encourage the teacher to expand task and example space to respond to the limitations noted within the teacher’s practice.
In this article, we report on the work of developing primary school teachers' mathematical knowledge for teaching (MKfT) in research-led ways. We share data of a Grade 2 teacher who participated in a follow-up to an in-service professional development ‘maths for teaching’ course in 2012. The follow-up consisted of a lesson observation and a subsequent video-stimulated recall interview, with reflections guided by the structure of Rowland et al.'s ‘knowledge quartet’. Our findings point to potential for ongoing learning beyond in-service course participation, with a research-led framework supporting the teacher to bring (perhaps) tacit assumptions of prerequisite skills explicitly to the fore. The article concludes with an appraisal of how research can directly feed into design focused on substantive development of MKfT.
On return to campus after the pandemic, students were subjected to receiving lectures online, in class, or by the emerging hybrid approach. This study reports students' preference over the three approaches based on the experience gained during the 2022/23 academic session. One hundred and twenty-seven (127) on-campus Education students in one public university in Malaysia participated in the study. Data was collected through an online forum and interviews with the participants. The data collected was analyzed using content and thematic analysis. Preference for the hybrid approach emerged as a finding with three themes describing what makes the wholly online class unpopular (themes one and two); and, the popularity of the hybrid approach (theme three): 1. On-campus learner-environment challenges; 2. Perceived lack of Faculty engagement and support in the online learning environment; and, 3. Student engagement through faculty presence and technology innovation. What the students valued most in the hybrid approach is the face-to-face technology-enhanced classroom interaction that is retained, believing that learning is more effective and interesting in class than online. They considered the additional online learning activities as complementing the classroom learning. The approach provides an opportunity for fundamental learning in class and supplementary learning online. These findings imply that institutions should prioritize technology integration into face-to-face instruction, leveraging innovative approaches to enhance student engagement and learning outcomes. Lecturers should consider adopting hybrid teaching models that combine the benefits of in-person interaction with the flexibility of online learning, catering to diverse student preferences and optimizing the educational experience.
This article contributes to the body of research on equivalence relations by delineating the levels of sophistication and efficiency in the intuitive strategies employed by pre-service teachers (PSTs). Using an inductive approach, we analysed 1102 responses to two open equivalence relations problems, drawn from a 27-item baseline assessment, completed by 551 first-year PSTs across three cohorts (2022–2024). From the analysis, we began teasing out a conceptual framework that could explain the reasoning behind the responses. To authenticate the conceptual framework, we needed to unearth the strategies employed by PSTs, so we conducted follow-up task-based interviews with nine selected participants. These interviews provided insights into the reasoning behind the PSTs’ written responses and helped illuminate the developmental progression in their understanding of reasoning when solving equivalence relations problem. In particular, our analysis of the interviews revealed three distinct stages of sophistication (quantitative, additive, and multiplicative) and four levels of efficiency in PSTs’ reasoning when solving equivalence relations problems. The findings show that PSTs encountered significant difficulties with solving open equivalence relations problems, with 46% correct responses: 14% of which involved quantity-based reasoning, while 17% and 15% were additive and multiplicative-based reasoning. Interestingly, in 2023, multiplicative-based reasoning (which is the most sophisticated of the three types of reasoning), had the highest responses at 21.1%, compared to 11.4% in 2022 and 11.2% in 2024. Moreover, the strategy that involves working with a large equivalence difference (which strategy is the least efficient) was found to be the predominant strategy in the PSTs’ workings within the additive-based reasoning. Thus, these interview findings provided deeper insights into the patterns observed in the written responses regarding PSTs’ intuitive strategies. Contribution: These findings provide insights into a possible teaching framework that delineates the stages of sophistication that students go through in the development of their knowledge of open equivalence relations problems. By introducing and classifying open equivalence relations problems as belonging to the Comparative Relational category of equivalence tasks, this study elaborates on the highest category of equivalence tasks. Also, this study offers a possible analytical framework for analysing levels of efficiency in students’ reasoning when solving open equivalence relations problems. Consequently, the findings have implications for teacher training programmes and intervention studies with an interest in building sophistication and efficiency into PSTs’ strategies for solving open equivalence relations problems.