The ability to accurately quantify biodiversity is fundamental to understanding ecological trends, identifying drivers of declines, and selecting effective conservation options. Scientists and resource managers have grappled with what metrics best show relevant biodiversity patterns and are still practical enough to aid on-the-ground resource conservation. Our purpose is to construct empirically derived, functional habitat guilds for prairie stream fish, then recommend future directions for constructing and using diversity metrics that aid field-based conservation. Working in the Upper Neosho River, KS, USA, we used univariate methods, cluster analysis, non-metric multi-dimensional scaling, and an analysis of similarity to functionally group stream fish taxa. The 11 most abundant fish species grouped into seven ecological guilds: riffle specialist, pool specialist, riffle generalist, pool generalist, riffle–run generalist, pool–run generalist, and generalist. Combining the habitat type and strength of association added ecological accuracy to our species groups. Employing multiple statistical methods increased confidence and generality in our grouping results. Moving forward will require a coordinated, coalition-driven, conservation-related strategy on which researchers and practitioners collaborate to synthesize diverse empirical results, organize general principles of structure and function, and balance accuracy with practicality.
A persistent challenge in fisheries is that field data sets from related studies are often difficult to compare and extend across years and systems. Examples include (1) surveys of native or invasive organisms conducted in one watershed may not predict trends in another watershed; (2) fish stocking protocols that result in high survival in one year may not produce the same results in subsequent years; and (3) data from single-period, single-location creel surveys may not represent angler attitudes, reactions, or preferences in other systems at other times. In our Strategic Connections Applied Across Leveraged Evaluations (SCAALE) framework, we develop a general model to address the knowledge gaps of how to better link related data sets, coordinate relevant perspectives, and merge individual data streams across years, systems, and taxa. We apply SCAALE to three case studies and show an example of the framework for fisheries agency planning. Whereas some external barriers to multi-study strategic planning can be modified through professional resolve (e.g., lack of training in strategic project planning), other barriers may require more extensive discussions (e.g., how funding is allocated). The SCAALE framework provides a relevant and practical approach that manager–researcher–administrator teams could use to advance data syntheses across years, systems, species, and projects. Our perspective initiates this profession-wide conversation.