Im Bereich der öffentlichen Unternehmen bestehen aufgrund der fortschreitenden europäischen Integration heute auch auf kommunaler Ebene rechtliche Unsicherheiten. Der folgende Beitrag zeigt dies an zwei aktuellen Beispielen anhand grundsätzlicher Überlegungen.
27 April 2010 in Zeitschrift für öffentliches Recht
Urban drainage networks (UDNs) are designed to reliably discharge wastewater and stormwater, with machine learning (ML) increasingly leveraged for a wide range of applications. A legal assessment of the European 'Artificial Intelligence Act' (AI Act) indicates that, while UDNs are considered part of critical infrastructure, ML applications in this field are generally not classified as high-risk AI systems, being subject to specific implementation requirements. Nevertheless, aspects such as model explainability are important to align with best practices in ML model development. In this context, two ML models (i.e., purely data-driven and physics-leveraged) used herein as surrogates for hydrodynamic modelling to predict combined sewer flow, were adapted from the authors' previous work and enhanced with various explainable AI techniques such as SHapley Additive exPlanations and robustness scores for a comprehensive understanding of the models' decision-making processes. The analysis revealed that the engineered classification into dry or wet flow is the most important feature for both ML models, followed by historical rainfall features for the purely data-driven ML model and hydrodynamic model outputs for the physics-leveraged ML model. Additionally, the achievable accuracy of both utilised ML models was highly sensitive to deviations in rainfall data, further limiting their reliability and trustworthiness.
The accurate prediction of daily drinking water demand for the next few days is the basis for many operational decisions and applications. In Europe, recently, the “Artificial Intelligence (AI) Act” was authorised, emphasising the trustworthiness and explainability of AI in the future. We therefore test and compare different AI methods regarding their performance, transparency and robustness. As the results show, opaque models are not per se superior to linear models, whereas linear models are especially ahead in terms of robustness and transparency. Bayesian linear models are particularly interesting as they additionally output credible intervals indicating upper and lower estimation bounds.