This paper investigates the socio-economic impacts of the driving restriction zone policy for the Paris region, using the multi-agent transport simulation MATSim. Based on a previous work which has calibrated a first instantiation of the mobility model to the Paris region, we extend it by modeling and simulating two forms of intermodality: Park-and-Walk and Park-and-Ride. After re-calibrating the model, we evaluate two policy scenarios featuring different scales of the restriction zone, using indicators related to mobility, traffic emissions, and social cost. The analysis puts special attention on how modal shift and emissions vary across space, that is, inside and outside the policy zone. We find that the small-scale scenario with a restriction zone limited to the Paris center leads to very limited modal shift, whereas the larger-scale policy scenario encompassing the whole of Paris shifts significantly more trips (about 1.4% of total trips) from cars to public transport and other modes. In both scenarios, traffic emissions decline in the restriction zone and its near surroundings. Far from the restriction zone, however, emissions increase in the small-scale scenario but decrease in the large-scale scenario. These differences are caused by the traffic detour, modal shift, and rebound effects, the magnitudes of which vary depending on the scale of the restriction zone. The driving restrictions also cause the social cost to increase by around 10% in both scenarios. This ultimately implies a trade-off between reducing emissions and increasing user costs, with a substantially greater efficiency (larger reduction for similar cost) in the large-scale policy scenario.
22 February 2025 in Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment
The study on individual mobility patterns supports our better understanding of spatiotemporal characteristics of people’s travel behavior and social activities. The mobile phone GPS data are advantageous due to the large size of their data coverage. This paper aims to identify individual activity anchor places and to analyze related patterns based on the GPS data collected from thousands of mobile phone users over four months in Greater Paris, France. We propose a method to refine the identification of home and secondary activities. Based on this, the mobility spatial characteristics are aggregated by applying a three-stage clustering method. As a consequence, the clusters of activity types, the daily mobility patterns (day types), and the user groups with similar daily mobility patterns are obtained stage by stage. This allows us to analyze the obtained clusters in a cascading maneuver by three different levels: activity level, day level, and individual level. Inversely, the mobility characteristics per user group are interpreted with respect to the interpretation of day types and then activity types. From the interpretable clusters, it is facilitated for us to find the daily mobility differences by user groups across weekdays and weekends, transport modes, as well as the mobility variability over the study period.
La mobilité des personnes dépend à la fois de l’offre de service de transports, et de l’organisation de notre espace de vie. Nos choix de localisation de résidence, de travail, ainsi que nos choix de déplacement et d’itinéraire dépendent de nos budgets monétaires, temporels et de nos préférences. L’organisation de notre espace de vie a donc de fortes répercussions sur les consommations d’espace et d’énergie. Peut-on concevoir notre espace de vie en 2040 sous une forme plus sobre ? Pour parvenir à un nouvel équilibre, nous proposons, sur le terrain de l’agglomération lilloise, d’appliquer le concept urbanistique théorique du Transit-Oriented-Development et son modèle du Corridor Urbain. Nos objectifs consistent à concentrer les activités de tous types le long des axes de Transports Collectifs lourds existants, ainsi, à redévelopper la métropole dans ses corridors afin de promouvoir une vie de proximité. En limitant l’urbanisation en dehors des espaces de corridors, nous maîtrisons l’étalement urbain et facilitons une mobilité durable. Pour tester un tel scénario, un modèle de simulation intégrée est mis en place incluant à la fois l’usage des espaces et le réseau complet des transports. Trois visions de stratégie territoriale en matière de réaménagement sont testées afin de mesurer les conséquences à long terme sur la morphologie des espaces et sur les mobilités humaines pour des activités diverses, ainsi que les effets environnementaux liés à ces actions. En plus d’enrichir la compréhension du système complexe qu’est la ville, les résultats issus de cette étude prospective apportent des indications pour l’organisation spatiale et pour la conception de la mobilité.