Andrew Skotnicki

Dr. Andrew Skotnicki


Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

18Years (2009-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
4 May 2014 in Criminal Justice Ethics
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
ASAndrew Skotnicki
Andrew Skotnicki
Rehabilitation and conversion within the penal context are deeply ambiguous concepts. This ambiguity stems in part from the fact that little consensus has been reached among scholars as to the meaning of the terms beyond their ability to foster adjustment to institutional rules and obedience to law. This paper argues that each concept receives greater clarity and practical significance when understood in terms of moral transformation. The article will utilize the methodological framework of social scientific studies to underscore a contention, most commonly found in theological literature that conversion, and a fortiori rehabilitation, signal a shift from a divided to a unified consciousness based upon the experience of unconditional acceptance and, ultimately, its bestowal upon others and upon all forms of life.

14 October 2025 in Histories
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
ASAndrew Skotnicki
Andrew Skotnicki
KLKarol Lucken
Karol Lucken
This article critiques penal philosophy and practice in contemporary society through the lens of historical–ecclesial tradition. The article opens with a discussion of the penitential rituals in the first Christian monasteries and the eventual adoption of some of these rituals in the earliest state penitentiaries in the U.S. It is argued that a nonviolent and coherent penal ideology was advocated from the inception of Christian monasticism and subsequently maintained over the centuries due to three paradigmatic values and commitments. These values and commitments, which form the basis of the critique, are a theological metanarrative, a moral ontology, and a belief in sin as an existential fact. These tenets are used to interrogate the traditional justifications of punishment that have guided government policy throughout modern history, in the U.S. and abroad.


1 January 2023 in Journal of Catholic Social Thought
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
ASAndrew Skotnicki
Andrew Skotnicki
VUVillanova University
Villanova University
In this article, the author argues that Catholic magisterial teaching in matters pertaining to criminal justice has been frozen since the Middle Ages in a legalist framework that has underwritten and continues to legitimate the violence of retributive justice by the state. The article will first provide the official Catholic position on criminal detention and punishment. This will be followed by a survey of the medieval, largely Thomist, account of the legitimacy of punishment as administered by the state, blessed by the Church, and dominant in Catholic teaching, to the demotion of the nonviolent, evangelical emphases that characterized the pre-Constantinian Church. Finally, the paper will urge the revoking of Catholic endorsement of inflicting willful suffering on criminal offenders found guilty in courts of law. In this way, the Catholic Church will maintain a consistent, life-affirming, and exemplary Christian ethic of criminal justice.

29 November 2023 in Theological Studies
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
ASAndrew Skotnicki
Andrew Skotnicki
The concept of purely penal law, as developed by the Spanish Jesuit Francisco Suárez in the early seventeenth century, argues that promulgated law is neither morally binding upon the citizen nor conceived as a moral requirement by legislators. Rather, the law is strictly punitive in its intent and function. The theory, which grants the individual the right to determine law’s rational and moral significance, touched off a heated debate that has been renewed at various times in history yet has not resurfaced since the mid-twentieth century. This article argues for the veracity and legitimacy of the concept in light of contemporary legal and penal dynamics. It also argues that the Catholic Church should take notice of its insights in its understanding of the relationship between church and state.

21 March 2019
Verified
Book Chapter
Closed access
ASAndrew Skotnicki
Andrew Skotnicki
The revolution needed in criminal justice begins with the sense that in the human drama to varying degrees all are sacred and all are villains. This universal human contradiction is reconciled through conversion–the expansion of intellectual, moral, and spiritual vision to include to an ever–widening degree everyone and everything. No one ever needs to be punished to achieve this level of integrity since the longing for participation and full communion is a property of the human spirit. Thus, the only persons who need criminal detention are the wilfully violent and predatory-not for the purpose of punishment but as members of a community of wounded healers who are loved into sociability.