Introduction: Behavioral measurement‐based care (MBC) can improve patient outcomes and has also been advanced as a critical learning health system (LHS) tool for identifying and mitigating potential disparities in mental health treatment. However, little is known about the uptake of remote behavioral MBC in safety net settings, or possible disparities occurring in remote MBC implementation.Methods: This study uses electronic health record data to study variation in completion rates at the clinic and patient level of a remote MBC symptom measure tool during the first 6 months of implementation at three adult outpatient psychiatry clinics in a safety net health system. Provider‐reported barriers to MBC adoption were also measured using repeated surveys at one of the three sites.Results: Out of 1219 patients who were sent an MBC measure request, uptake of completing at least one measure varied by clinic: General Adult Clinic, 38% (n = 262 of 696); Substance Use Clinic, 28% (n = 73 of 265); and Transitions Clinic, 17% (n = 44 of 258). Compared with White patients, Black and Portuguese or Brazilian patients had lower uptake. Older patients also had lower uptake. Spanish language of care was associated with much lower uptake at the patient level. Significant patient‐level disparities in uptake persisted after adjusting for the clinic, mental health diagnoses, and number of measure requests sent. Providers cited time within visits and bandwidth in their workflow as the greatest consistent barriers to discussing MBC results with patients.Conclusions: There are significant disparities in MBC uptake at the patient and clinic level. From an LHS data infrastructure perspective, safety net health systems may need to address the need for possible ways to adapt MBC to better fit their populations and clinical needs, or identify targeted implementation strategies to close data gaps for the identified disparity populations.
Introduction: Psychiatric measurement‐based care (MBC) can be more effective than usual care, but health systems face implementation challenges. Achieving attitudinal alignment before implementing MBC is critical, yet few studies incorporate perspectives from multiple stakeholders this early in planning. This analysis identifies alignment and themes in pre‐implementation feedback from patients, providers, and administrators regarding a planned MBC implementation in a safety net psychiatry clinic.Methods: We used interview guides informed by Conceptual Model of Implementation Research to gather qualitative pre‐implementation attitudes about perceived Appropriateness, Acceptability, and Feasibility of an MBC measure (Computerized Adaptive Test—Mental Health; CAT‐MH) from five patients, two providers, and six administrators. We applied rapid qualitative analysis methods to generate actionable feedback for department leadership still planning implementation. [Correction added on 22 January 2025, after first online publication: In the previous sentence, the word ‘general’ was replaced with the word ‘generate’.] We used a multistep process to generate thematic findings with potential relevance for other similar mental health settings.Results: There was more attitudinal alignment across stakeholder groups regarding MBC's Acceptability and Feasibility than its Appropriateness. All three groups agreed that it was important to contextualize MBC for patients and providers, anticipate MBC's impact on patient–provider relationships, and consider the system's capacity to respond to patient needs unearthed by CAT‐MH before implementation began. Our thematic analysis suggests: (1) Introducing MBC may complicate patient–provider relationships by adding a new and potentially conflicting input for decision making, that is, MBC data, to the more typical inputs of patient report and provider expertise; [Correction added on 22 January 2025, after first online publication: In the previous sentence, the word ‘complicated’ was replaced with the word ‘complicate’.] (2) MBC poses theoretical risks to health equity for safety net patients because of limitations in access to MBC tools themselves and the resources needed to respond to MBC data; and (3) Tension exists between individual‐ and system‐level applications of MBC.Conclusions: Our analysis highlights shifting treatment dynamics, equity considerations, and tension between individual‐ and population‐level needs that our participants anticipated when planning for MBC implementation in a safety net psychiatry clinic.
Objective: The objective of this study was to explore the acceptability and feasibility of a therapeutic assessment protocol for the Screening and Support of Youth (SASY). SASY provides brief but comprehensive community-based screening and support for diverse youth in the community. Methods: SASY screening evaluates symptoms, functioning and clinical risk. The Kiddie Computerized Adaptive Test was used to evaluate seven different diagnoses and symptom severity. The Weiss Functional Impairment Rating Scale-Self was used to measure functional impairment. Measures were scored according to nationally developed norms. An algorithm was developed to aggregate symptom and function ratings into an overall score for clinical risk. The results are discussed with participants in a motivational interview designed to promote insight, followed by the opportunity for the participant to engage in an online intervention. Protocol changes necessitated by social distancing during the pandemic led to innovative methods including the use of a QR code for recruitment, integration of both online and offline participation, and expansion from in-person recruitment within the schools to virtual engagement with youth throughout the community. The final sample included disproportionately more Black or African American and Hispanic youth as compared to school and community statistics, suggesting that optimization of online and offline methods in research may facilitate the recruitment of diverse populations. Qualitative interviews indicated that the screening and feedback raised youth awareness of their wellbeing and/or distress, its impact on their functioning, and engagement with options for improved wellbeing. Conclusions: The emergence of innovative methods optimizing the advantages of both online and offline methods, developed as a necessity during the pandemic, proved advantageous to the feasibility and acceptability of community-based recruitment of at-risk, minoritized youth.
Background: Measurement-based care (MBC), including remote MBC, is increasingly being considered or implemented for mental health treatment and outcomes monitoring in routine clinical care. However, little is known about the health equity implications in real-world practice or the impact on patient-provider relationships in lower-resource systems that offer mental health treatment for diverse patients. Objective: This hypothesis-generating study examined the drivers of MBC implementation outcomes, the implications for health equity, and the impact of MBC on therapeutic alliance (TA). The study was conducted 1 year after the implementation of remote MBC at 3 outpatient adult clinics in a diverse, safety-net health system. Methods: This explanatory sequential mixed methods study used quantitative surveys and qualitative focus groups with mental health care providers. Repeated surveys were first used to understand mental health care provider experiences over a 6-month period, at least 1 year after MBC implementation. Surveys were analyzed to refine focus group prompts. Six mental health providers participated in repeated surveys over 6 months, after which the same 6 providers and 1 additional mental health provider took part in focus groups. Results: Surveys revealed stable acceptability and utility ratings, concerns that MBC was not equally benefiting patients, little endorsement that MBC improved TA, and slightly decreasing feasibility scores. In focus groups, mental health care providers shared concerns about the acceptability, appropriateness, feasibility, and equity of processes for collecting MBC data. These providers had less first-hand experience with sharing and acting upon the data but still voiced concerns about the processes for doing so. TA both impacted and was impacted by MBC in positive and negative ways. The potential drivers of the findings are discussed using qualitative data. Conclusions: More than 1 year after the implementation of remote MBC for mental health, mental health care providers had enduring concerns about its implications for health equity as well as its bidirectional relationship with TA. These findings suggest that further study is needed to identify system-level strategies to mitigate potential negative effects of real-world MBC implementations on health equity, particularly in low-resource settings with diverse populations.