Variety selection in perennial pasture crops involves identifying best varieties from data collected from multiple harvest times in field trials. For accurate selection, the statistical methods for analysing such data need to account for the spatial and temporal correlation typically present. This paper provides an approach for analysing multi-harvest data from variety selection trials in which there may be a large number of harvest times. Methods are presented for modelling the variety by harvest effects while accounting for the spatial and temporal correlation between observations. These methods provide an improvement in model fit compared to separate analyses for each harvest, and provide insight into variety by harvest interactions. The approach is illustrated using two traits from a lucerne variety selection trial. The proposed method provides variety predictions allowing for the natural sources of variation and correlation in multi-harvest data.
16 December 2016 in Journal of Agricultural, Biological and Environmental Statistics
Context: In order to identify best crop genotypes for recommendation to breeders, and ultimately for use in breeding, evaluation is usually conducted in field trials across a range of environments, known as multi-environment trials. Increasingly, many breeding traits are measured over time, for example with high-throughput phenotyping at different growth stages in annual crops or repeated harvests in perennial crops. Aims: This study aims to provide an efficient, accurate approach for modelling genotype response over time and across environments, accounting for non-genetic sources of variation such as spatial and temporal correlation. Methods: Because the aim is genotype selection, genetic effects are fitted as random effects, and so the approach is based on random regression, in which linear or non-linear models are used to model genotype responses. A method for fitting random regression is outlined in a multi-environment situation, using underlying cubic smoothing splines to model the mean trend over time. This approach is illustrated on six wheat experiments, using data on grain-filling over thermal time. Key results: The method correlates genetic effects over time and environments, providing predicted genotype responses while incorporating spatial and temporal correlation between observations. Conclusions: The approach provides robust genotype predictions by accounting for temporal and spatial effects simultaneously under various situations including those in which trials have different measurement times or where genotypes within trials are not measured at the same times. The approach facilitates investigation into genotype by environment interaction (G × E) both within and across environments. Implications: The models presented have potential to increase accuracy of predictions over measurement times and trials, provide predictions at times other than those observed, and give a greater understanding of G × E interaction, hence improving genotype selection across environments for repeated-measures traits.
Nut set is an important determinant of yield and plays a pivotal role in orchard profitability. The complex process of nut setting is governed by numerous factors, with pollination being a critical mechanism. Macadamia cultivars exhibit both self- and cross-pollination. Self-pollination may increase nut set, so it is a trait of interest in breeding. This study investigated nut setting and nutlet abscission on four cultivars, ‘HAES 791’, ‘HAES 741’, ‘HAES 344’, and ‘A16’, using three controlled self-pollination methods: (i) autogamy (AG), entailing bagging before anthesis with no hand-pollination; (ii) geitonogamy 1 (GG1), bagging following hand-pollination using pollen from the same raceme; and (iii) geitonogamy 2 (GG2), bagging following hand-pollination using pollen from different racemes of the same cultivar. These self-pollination methods were compared against open-pollination (OP). ‘HAES 741’ and ‘HAES 791’ were partially self-fertile, while ‘HAES 344’ and ‘A16’ were self-infertile. Final nut sets per raceme for ‘HAES 741’ were 0.43 by AG, 0.65 by GG1, and 0.5 by GG2, and for ‘HAES 791’, they were 0.90 by AG, 1.25 by GG1, and 1.0 by GG2. Final nut set per raceme with OP was higher compared to self-pollination methods and ranged between 3.5–6.5. In self-fertile cultivars, nut set following the three self-pollination methods accounted for 6.5–3.7% of the nut set following OP, and nutlet abscission following self-pollination methods accounted for 20–50% of nutlet abscission following OP. No significant differences in nut set and nutlet abscission were observed among AG, GG1, and GG2. Results suggest that macadamia orchards planted with self-fertile cultivars would be less reliant on external pollinators or artificial pollination to achieve adequate yields.
Context: Perennial crop variety selection trials are often conducted over several seasons or years. These field trials often exhibit spatial correlation between plots. When data from multiple assessment times are analysed, it is necessary to account for both spatial and temporal correlation. A current approach is to use linear mixed models with separable spatial and temporal residual covariance structures. A limitation of these separable models is that they assume the same spatial correlation structure for each assessment time, which may not hold in practice. Aims: This study aims to provide more flexible methods for modelling the spatio-temporal correlation in multi-assessment perennial crop data, allowing for differing spatial parameters for each time, together with modelling genetic effects over time. Methods: The paper investigates the suitability of two-directional invariant multivariate autoregressive (2DIMVAR1) models for analysis of multi-assessment perennial crop data. The analysis method is applied to persistence data from a pasture breeding trial. Key results: The multivariate autoregressive spatio-temporal residual models are a significant improvement on separable residual models under different genetic models. The paper demonstrates how to fit the models in practice using the software ASReml-R. Conclusions: A flexible modelling approach for multi-assessment perennial crop data is presented, allowing differing spatial correlation parameters for each time. The models allow investigation into genotype × time interactions, while optimally accounting for spatial and temporal correlation. Implications: The models provide improvements on current approaches and hence will result in more accurate genetic predictions in multi-assessment perennial crop variety selection trials.