Many countries, including the United Kingdom, have committed to reaching “net zero” emissions by 2050. To meet this challenge requires urgent deployment of low-carbon energy-generating technologies, not just for electricity generation but also other sectors, including transportation and heating. However, this will only be successful if the other two pillars of sustainability (social and economic impacts) are balanced with the environmental drivers. All energy-generation technologies have benefits and drawbacks, and these must be objectively and fairly assessed using a “level playing field” approach. Nuclear energy has benefits that are complementary to renewables and thus can play a valuable role in delivering large amounts of low-carbon energy globally. However, critics of nuclear energy raise concerns related to safety (and security), radioactive waste management, and economics that have challenged its acceptance as a sustainable energy source in some quarters. Nevertheless, objective consideration of sustainability in global energy needs and the different generating technologies clearly indicate a valuable role for nuclear energy in a sustainable and low-carbon future. It is concluded that nuclear energy should be recognised as “sustainable”, and the analysis shows that energy portfolios incorporating nuclear provide the most sustainable system overall.
Ensuring economic supplies of secure, affordable and clean energy is a global sustainability challenge. Previous studies have shown that, on balance, nuclear energy, based on today’s dominant light water reactors with the once-through use of nuclear fuel, compares well with renewable energy technologies and so should be considered a sustainable energy source. However, the energy-producing nuclear reactor requires a complex infrastructure around it to produce the fuel and to deal with highly radioactive products. The end-to-end fuel cycle thus has significant implications when assessing the overall sustainability of nuclear energy and the “most sustainable” pathways for future nuclear energy. The simplest fuel cycle option is the Once-Through Cycle (OTC) with disposal of used nuclear fuels. More technologically complex options involve different degrees of closing the fuel cycle by recycling and reusing materials from the used fuels. This paper defines six options with different degrees of materials recycling—innovatively presenting them in the form of a “Tube Map” based on that of the London Underground system. The results of this critical review show that recycling has positive impacts on the use of natural resources, environmental footprint, management of high-level radioactive wastes, and energy security. Challenges to the acceptance of closed cycles, however, include safety, security, proliferation, and economics; but our preliminary analysis shows either that solutions exist or that they are not discriminating factors in the choice of fuel cycle. To address these issues, it is important to learn from past experience of implementing closed cycles, and this review looks at the United Kingdom as an interesting case study. Overall, it is concluded that whilst nuclear energy per se should be recognised as sustainable, when implementing the OTC, the development of closed fuel cycles should be considered as a strategic choice that can enhance the overall sustainability of the system. Lastly, an update to the “level playing field” analysis previously proposed for analysing different energy systems is made to account for the differences between different nuclear fuel cycle choices. The only factors that are worse for closed cycles than the OTC are the lower technological maturity (due to greater technological complexity) of closed cycles—particularly those with multiple recycling—and proliferation resistance and physical security (due to the separation of materials in closed cycles).
The Euratom HARPERS (HARmonised PracticEs, Regulations and Standards in waste management and decommissioning) project aims to establish and clarify the benefits and added value of a more aligned practices, methodologies and approaches for prioritised topics related to decommissioning and initial phases of radioactive waste handling, including shared processing facilities between Member States (MS). The HARPERS project has a two-phase approach: the first phase involves engaging with Stakeholders to assess needs and pros/cons for harmonisation and to identify priority areas for deeper analysis. The second phase will pursue deeper engagement with Stakeholders to further assess the highest ranked priority areas in the three technical Work Packages. In Phase 2 the industry and business impacts resulting from the project findings will be also evaluated. Work Package 4 (WP4) of HARPERS project is focused on addressing the most important conditions and opportunities for promoting Circular Economy approaches when managing materials and waste arising from nuclear decommissioning across Europe. For the prioritisation of needs and opportunities for Circular Economy considerations, a detailed list of topics (challenges/needs - related to alignment of practices and approaches) has been developed. Topics were clustered into 7 main categories and discussed with interested external stakeholders during dedicated on-line workshops conducted in January and February 2023. Criteria for the prioritisation of topics, based on drivers relating to societal impacts, actor-specific impacts, scientific impacts and financial impacts, have been developed and discussed during the workshops too. This work presents the preliminary outcomes of the two online workshops.