Background and Objectives: Amyloidosis is a disorder characterized by the abnormal folding of proteins, forming insoluble fibrils that accumulate in tissues and organs. This accumulation disrupts normal tissue architecture and organ function, often with serious consequences, including death if left untreated. Light-chain amyloidosis (AL) and hereditary transthyretin-type amyloidosis (hATTR) are two of the most common types. In amyloidosis, peripheral nervous system involvement is a significant diagnostic feature, particularly when it manifests as polyneuropathy, carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS), and dysautonomia. These neurological symptoms often point to the involvement of amyloid deposits in the peripheral and autonomic nervous systems, which can help identify and differentiate between the various types of amyloidosis. Materials and Methods: This retrospective study focused on the evolution of electrophysiological parameters in two groups: AL (n = 22) and hATTR-Glu54Gln patients (n = 14), with mixed axonal polyneuropathy. Patients were followed for two consecutive years to assess disease progression. The PND scale (polyneuropathy disability) was also used to assess motor impairment for each patient. Results: In our study AL amyloidosis patients presented with mixed, axonal polyneuropathy associated with CTS in 63.6% of cases and cardiomyopathy (45.5%). Serial EMGs (electromyography) showed decreased motor amplitudes of the common peroneal and tibial nerves and sensory amplitude of the superficial peroneal nerve, with mostly preserved conduction velocities. The patients maintained stage I PND throughout the monitoring period. The entire hATTR group displayed mixed, axonal polyneuropathy and cardiomyopathy; 85.7% of them had CTS, and 42.9% had orthostatic hypotension. EMG data showed decreased motor amplitudes of the tibial and common peroneal nerves, decreased sensory amplitudes of the superficial peroneal nerve, and mildly reduced conduction velocities, with significant progression at 12 and 24 months. The patients displayed additional reduced muscle strength, some reaching stage 3A and 3B-PND at the end of the study. Conclusions: The amyloidotic polyneuropathy found in the groups was similar in its axonal, sensory-motor, and length-dependent characteristics, but the study showed significant differences in its progression, with more abrupt changes in the hATTR-Glu54Gln group. The amyloidosis AL patients remained in stage 1 PND, while the hATTR-Glu54Gln patients progressed to stage 3 PND at 24 months.