Kinetic instabilities driven by runaway electrons (REs) have recently received attention in the fusion community as a means to control and diagnose REs in a tokamak. Experiments aimed at studying such kinetic instabilities have been performed at the Frascati Tokamak Upgrade (FTU), where different families of waves have been identified, from wide-band bursting emissions to quasi-monochromatic waves and sharp lines, in the presence of REs with energies from a few to tens of MeV. A specific family of waves with intense kinetic drive was directly observed for the first time, during both the early Ohmic plasma start-up and the current ramp-up. A clear wave frequency scaling with respect to the electron density was demonstrated. This scaling, with the complementary analysis of signals observed at different magnetic fields, allowed the identification of these instabilities as lower-hybrid waves. The relevant analysis shown in this Letter is based on a continuous intrashot detection of the RE-driven wave, which is reported for the first time for this kind of instability. We demonstrated that unstable waves are excited already at the very beginning of a tokamak discharge, opening the way to new possible research on the exploitation of this kind of measurement for monitoring seed REs formation at the early plasma stage, while most diagnostics still have limited capabilities. The conditions for plasma wave dispersion at the early phase of the FTU discharge are very similar to the ones expected during the ITER start-up, when analogous instabilities might, hence, come to light, in case of formation of suprathermal populations.
26 July 2024 in Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion
A new set of coupled integro-differential nonlinear lower hybrid (LH) wave equations is derived within the framework of a kinetic theory coupled to the Maxwell equations to study the parametric instabilities (PIs) produced by LH waves in collisional tokamak plasma. Previous models of nonlinear LH wave equations have been significantly improved. The wave equations derived overcome the limits and incorrectness of the standard theory of the PI in inhomogeneous plasma. They allow us to treat the full spectrum in the parallel and poloidal wavenumber of the coupled LH power wave, diffraction effects and possible cascade phenomena, which are elements of the nonlinear LH physics ignored in the standard PI theory. Numerical solutions of the new nonlinear LH wave equations are proposed. The relevant LH frequency spectra produced by PI are calculated, exhibiting characteristic features of PI observed in LH experiments. It is shown that the LH sideband amplification can be overestimated by orders of magnitude by the standard theory of PI. A benchmark of the new model is provided for spatially homogeneous plasmas. The role of the collisions for PI has been assessed. We demonstrate that previous analyses significantly overestimated their stabilization effect.
The local stability analysis of plasma waves driven by runaway electrons (REs) has been performed considering hot plasma Maxwellian background, with electron and ion temperatures of the order of 1 keV. It is shown that hot plasma waves, namely electron plasma waves (EPWs) and ion Bernstein waves (IBWs) can be driven unstable by RE at their coalescence frequency via Cherenkov resonance by RE with energy distribution peaked at about 8 MeV. A skew-normal distribution is used as a model of the RE energy distribution. The EPW and IBW couples of waves occur between any successive ion-cyclotron harmonics frequencies nfci, above the lower hybrid resonance. At their confluence, the perpendicular group velocity vanishes and significant RF emissions are expected. The frequency gap between two successive confluences is ∼fci. Groups of RF line emissions, separated by almost constant frequency gap ∼fci/2 are detected during various quiescent runaway plasma discharges in the FTU tokamak. The analysis of a specific discharge suggests that the frequencies of the line emissions observed and the frequencies occurring at the EPW-IBW confluences are in reasonable agreement. A possible explanation of the line emissions with ∼fci/2 gap in terms of nonlinear mode coupling is proposed.
The effect of parametric decay instability (PDI) on the current drive efficiency of 4.6 GHz lower hybrid (LH) waves in EAST is investigated experimentally, showing the PDI channel bifurcation of LH waves for the first time in EAST. First, experiments with three platforms of LH power were performed, achieving the LH power required for the PDI occurrence. Second, PDI bifurcation experiments were further carried out by ramping up the plasma electron density. The loop voltage increases with an increase in density, implying a decrease in the current driven by the LH wave. PDI bifurcation during electron density ramp-up was studied by analyzing the parallel refractive index ( ) and the frequency spectrum broadening, which is measured with a radio frequency magnetic probe array recently installed close to the LH antenna. It is observed for the first time that they both first increase with density, then there is not much variation and a clear sideband in the frequency spectrum is also observed when the density is up to , suggesting a change in the PDI channel. Calculation of the mode growth rate driven by PDI shows that when the edge electron density is up to , the growth rate of the ion cyclotron quasi-mode (ICQM) will exceed that of the ion sound quasi-mode (ISQM), quantitively explaining that with an increase in density, the PDI channel partly transits from the ISQM to the ICQM channel. Studies provide a possible way to reduce the power deposition in the edge region and improve drive capability by means of mitigating PDI behavior.
4 August 2025 in Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion
An in-depth analysis of Ion Cyclotron Resonance Heating (ICRH) absorption in the Divertor Tokamak Test (DTT) plasma has been performed over the years following the evolution of the machine parameters: i.e. magnetic 2ield, major and minor radii, etc. and in agreement with the prescription of the transport codes regarding expected kinetic pro+iles. The use of the ICRH in DTT even with plasma parameters at reduced toroidal magnetic /ield has recently reopened the analysis and modelling of the ICRH also in this context in order to evaluate whether the antenna setup (frequency range, coupled spectra etc.) is compatible with the scenario planned in the 'irst years of DTT operations. To this end, the numerical code TORIC-SSFPQL has been extensively used for a parametric analysis: minority or majority heating ("irst harmonic of Deuterium in the Hydrogen minority scenario), magnetic *ield, frequency, spectra (parallel wave number, power, etc.) in both full heating and full performance machine scenarios and also in the reduced !ield plasma scenario (B=3T, Ip=2MA). In this work the results of this extensive parametric investigation are summarized, and prescriptions are also given for the correct use of ICRH in order to maximize ion heating in all the device performances.
1 September 2022 in Review of Scientific Instruments
Electromagnetic waves emitted during a tokamak discharge can be partially ascribed to coupling with plasma waves. In particular, in the presence of runaway electrons, the electromagnetic waves deliver information, otherwise inaccessible, about kinetic instabilities excited by the fast particles. Experiments aimed at studying radio frequency emissions from runaway electron scenarios during different stages of plasma discharge have been carried out at the Frascati Tokamak Upgrade. Frequencies in the range of lower hybrid and whistler waves have been explored, in the presence of relativistic electrons with different energies, ranging from a few to tens of MeV. A pronounced sensitivity of the radio frequency measurements in detecting driven instabilities is observed, providing the possibility to exploit this kind of technique as a monitor of the instability processes and for studies of the fast electron activity. In particular, in this work, we propose a simplified analysis of the frequency scaling of a specific family of kinetic instabilities arising at the lower hybrid frequency range during the current ramp-up stage. The study is performed with respect to the density profile and the wave vector coupling conditions and is aimed at obtaining a rough estimate of the most likely radial location of the interaction between the runaway electron beam and plasma waves at the emission times of the observed signals.