This review paper identifies key stability and control screening parameters needed to design low-risk, general-purpose high-speed aircraft. These derive from MIL-STD-8785C, MIL-STD-1797, and older AGARD reports, and are suitable for assessing conceptual high-speed vehicles. We demonstrate their applicability using published ground test, computation, and flight test data from the Bell X-2, North American X-15, Martin X-24A, Northrop HL-10, Lockheed Blackbird (YF-12/SR-71), and North American XB-70 as well as the Rockwell Space Shuttle Orbiter. The relative success of the X-15 and Blackbird and the performance limitations of the others indicate the need to scrutinize lateral-directional stability at the preliminary design phase. Our work reveals the need for strong bare-airframe static directional stability to obtain favorable flying qualities.
This paper develops empirical relationships to estimate FAA/EASA and MIL-3013B rules-compliant take-off field performance for single and multi-engine aircraft. Recent experience with modern aircraft flight manuals revealed that popular empirical legacy methods are no longer accurate; improvements in tires and brakes lead to significantly shorter certified distances. This work relies upon a survey of current operational aircraft and extensive numerical simulations of generic configurations to support the development of a collection of new equations to estimate take-off performance for single and multi-engine aircraft under dry and wet conditions. These relationships are individually tailored for civilian and U.S. Military rules; they account for the superior capability of modern braking systems and the implications of minimum-control speed on the certified distance.
There is growing interest in the design of maneuvering high-speed aircraft to fly within or at the edge of the atmosphere. We identify and develop novel quasi-static vehicle screening methodologies, suitable for use during preliminary design, to better predict an incipient loss of control due to the dynamic effects of feedback. We validate these metrics by reverse-engineering Neil Armstrong’s 1962 loss of control and inadvertent atmospheric skip while piloting the X-15. In 1962, then-extant flight dynamics screening methods did not forecast likely troubles. We assemble and refine a collection of predictive metrics which operate upon basic quasi-static aerodynamic data and predict the confluence of lateral/directional stability and controllability issues which plagued the flown mission. These tools, which leverage McRuer’s “equivalent stability derivative” approach, enable future engineers to make proactive design changes which can avoid lateral/directional instabilities developing at high speeds.
This paper develops new empirical relationships to estimate FAA/EASA- and MIL-3013B-rules-compliant landing-field performance of multi-engine transport aircraft. Widely cited textbooks date from an era when inferior tire and braking capability limited aircraft performance. Today, the use of overly pessimistic conceptual design-level performance estimates may lead concept-design teams to advocate for unnecessary engineering solutions (for example, more complex flaps) to solve “problems” which do not actually exist. Moreover, today’s aircraft designer is likely to face customer-imposed wet and/or contaminated runway performance requirements, where the classic books only discussed dry-weather operations. Taken together, the design community needs a collection of revised empirical equations to estimate landing distances for dry and wet runways. The empirical relationships published here are based upon modern flight-manual data augmented by a calibrated physics-based numerical simulation applied to a wide range of possible vehicle configurations. They offer improved accuracy, compared to earlier methods. The new method, when applied to FAA rules for aircraft operating on dry runways, predicts the substantially shorter “real-world” certified landing distances attainable by modern aircraft.
This paper arises from an ARPA-E-sponsored project seeking design opportunities to retrofit existing aircraft with hybrid electric propulsion systems. Engineers typically configure aircraft to fly a given payload over a long range, which is subject to field performance constraints. In practice, operators fly transport aircraft (civilian and military) in a manner where dispatch consciously trades payload and/or range to enable safe operations to and from short runways. This work describes a simple yet novel analytical process suitable for inclusion in conceptual design or technology portfolio trade study evaluations to assess the impacts of weight-restricted dispatch upon usable payloads. We find that options that increase low-speed thrust may maintain or improve the useful payload even if it substantially increases aircraft fixed weight. Conversely, otherwise desirable technologies that decrease low-speed thrust may severely impact the useful payload of aircraft operating to and from short runways.