Adilbek K Bisenbaev

Dr. Adilbek K Bisenbaev

orcid
Open to global work in epistemology and science studies

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

37Years (1990-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
10 November 2025 in Publications
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
ABAdilbek K Bisenbaev
Adilbek K Bisenbaev
Modern approaches to research assessment often treat two independent dimensions: the degree of readiness (the progress of scientific maturity) and the Added Scientific Value (novelty, rigor, reproducibility, and societal significance). The present study aims to develop an integrative model that links the stepwise logic of Scientific Readiness Levels (SRLs) with the continuous evaluation of Added Scientific Value (ASV). To achieve this, we construct a two-dimensional quantitative framework, SRL × ASV, in which discrete readiness levels are combined with the multiplicative aggregation of normalized qualitative indicators—including novelty, rigor, reproducibility, openness, impact, and collaboration. Advancement to a higher readiness level becomes possible only when the evidential criteria are simultaneously satisfied and the ASV threshold value is reached. The model is formally defined and illustrated via the example of Kazakhstan’s national science funding system. The results demonstrate that the integration of SRL and ASV creates a reproducible and transparent decision-making structure in which weak components cannot be compensated by strong ones, and excessive dependence on purely metric-based evaluations is eliminated. By uniting maturity and quality within a single coherent system, the SRL + ASV model bridges the gap between developmental staging and scientific value, transforming research assessment into a transparent, evidence-based, and continuously improvable process applicable to the governance of responsible and reproducible science.

27 January 2026 in Philosophies
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
ABAdilbek K Bisenbaev
Adilbek K Bisenbaev
This article proposes a redefinition of scientific authorship under conditions of algorithmic mediation. We shift the discussion from the ontological dichotomy of “tool versus author” to an operationalizable epistemology of contribution. Building on the philosophical triad of instrumentality—intervention, representation, and hermeneutics—we argue that contemporary AI systems (notably large language models, LLMs) exceed the role of a merely “mute” accelerator of procedures. They now participate in the generation of explanatory structures, the reframing of research problems, and the semantic reconfiguration of the knowledge corpus. In response, we formulate the AI-AUTHorship framework, which remains compatible with an anthropocentric legal order while recognizing and measuring AI’s cognitive participation. We introduce TraceAuth, a protocol for tracing cognitive chains of reasoning, and AIEIS (AI epistemic impact score), a metric that stratifies contributions along the axes of procedural (P), semantic (S), and generative (G) participation. The threshold between “support” and “creation” is refined through a battery of operational tests (alteration of the problem space; causal/counterfactual load; independent reproducibility without AI; interpretability and traceability). We describe authorship as distributed epistemic authorship (DEA): a network of people, artifacts, algorithms, and institutions in which AI functions as a nonsubjective node whose contribution is nonetheless auditable. The framework closes the gap between the de facto involvement of AI and de jure norms by institutionalizing a regime of “recognized participation,” wherein transparency, interpretability, and reproducibility of cognitive trajectories become conditions for acknowledging contribution, whereas human responsibility remains nonnegotiable.

28 February 2023 in Economic Annals-ХХI
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
AEAltynsarin National Academy Of Education
Altynsarin National Academy Of Education
ABAdilbek K Bisenbaev
Adilbek K Bisenbaev
KBKulzhanat Bulatbayeva
Kulzhanat Bulatbayeva
DODuman Orynbekov
Duman Orynbekov
LUL. N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University
L. N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University
SASerik Azambayev
Serik Azambayev
The cultural model of science and the scientific system of Kazakhstan are theorized and updated for the first time in our research, and this study extends Hofstede’s five-dimensional model of cultural space specifically in the context of the scientific system. The methodology involves employing Hofstede’s dimensions – Power Distance, Individualism versus Collectivism, Masculinity versus Femininity, Uncertainty Avoidance, and Long-Term versus Short-Term Orientation – as a heuristic tool to evaluate the attributes of scientific culture in Kazakhstan. In this way, we shed light on how scientists in Kazakhstan interact with the prevailing cultural norms and expectations, offering a detailed view of culturally embedded scientific practices. To clarify, the five dimensions are adapted in the following manner: Firstly, Scientific Power Distance pertains to the degree of hierarchical authority within scientific institutions. High power distance in this setting implies a significant disparity between junior and senior researchers, thereby affecting the dynamics of collaboration and innovation. Secondly, Scientific Individualism-Collectivism measures the extent to which the scientific culture either fosters individual achievement and originality or prioritizes group cooperation. Thirdly, Scientific Masculinity-Femininity assesses the predominance of either competitive (Masculine) or collaborative (Feminine) traits within the scientific community. Fourthly, Scientific Uncertainty Avoidance deals with the community’s tolerance for uncertainty and ambiguity, indicating whether there’s a preference for structured environments. Lastly, Scientific Long-Term Orientation gauges the focus of scientific endeavors, whether they aim for immediate outputs or invest in long-term research. The Kazakhstan scientific system is thus situated within this adapted framework of five dimensions, providing an intricate mapping of how cultural attributes impact scientific pursuits in the country. The importance of cultural phenomenology in the scientific domain comes from its focus on the observation and interpretation of the cultural factors that influence scientific thinking, progress, and implementation. It recognizes that science is not an isolated activity but is deeply entrenched in societal and cultural systems. In the specific context of Kazakhstan, a country experiencing rapid socio-economic changes, the scientific system is not only shaped by various facets of cultural identity but also makes substantial contributions to socio-economic development. Regarding the empirical findings of this study, the data illustrates the profound economic impact of the scientific system in Kazakhstan. From increased R&D investment to job creation and attracting significant Foreign Direct Investment (FDI), the scientific system appears to make a direct and meaningful contribution to the nation’s economic growth and development. In conclusion, these findings suggest that there is a positive trajectory for the scientific culture in Kazakhstan, contributing both to socio-economic conditions and to the global scientific community.

1 March 1993 in Journal of Molecular Structure
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
ABAdilbek K Bisenbaev
Adilbek K Bisenbaev
LLL.V. Levshin
L.V. Levshin
ASA.M. Saletsky
A.M. Saletsky

28 February 2023 in Economic Annals-ХХI
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
YZYerkebulan Zhumashov
Yerkebulan Zhumashov
AEAltynsarin National Academy Of Education
Altynsarin National Academy Of Education
SASerik Azambayev
Serik Azambayev
ABAdilbek K Bisenbaev
Adilbek K Bisenbaev
AYAssyl Yessenzharov
Assyl Yessenzharov
N«National Center For Advanced Training «Orleu»
National Center For Advanced Training «Orleu»
Zhumashov, Ye., Azambayev, S., Bisenbaev, A., Yessenzharov, A., & Bulatbayeva, K. (2023). Economic Annals-XXI, 201(1-2), 73-83. doi: https://doi.org/10.21003/ea.V201-07

1 March 1992 in Journal of Molecular Structure
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
ABAdilbek K Bisenbaev
Adilbek K Bisenbaev
LLL.V. Levshin
L.V. Levshin
ASA.M. Saletsky
A.M. Saletsky