An inappropriate pilot hole size (PHS) is one of several factors that affects the stiffness of the screw-bone fixation. The present study uses finite element models to investigate the effect of varying the PHS on the biomechanical environment of the screw-bone interface of the fractured bone, after the screw insertion and under the immediate body weight pressure (BWP). Four PHS from 71% up to 85% of the screw external diameter (SED) were considered for analysis. A non linear material behaviour of the bone with ductile damage properties was used in the study. To validate the numerical models, an experimental pull-out test was carried out using a synthetic bone. The results of the insertion process demonstrated that the relatively smaller holes (71% and 75.5% of SED) increased the insertion torque value within the recommended level, caused more bone radial extension deformation and maximized the contact area between the bone threads and the screw, in comparison to the PHS higher than 80% of SED. Under the immediate BWP after osteosynthesis, the stress level exceeds the elastic limit and becomes high enough to initiate the ductile damage of the bone. Also, enlarging PHS from 71% to 75.5% of SED increased the bone microdisplacement at the screw-bone interface from 75 up to 100 μm, and that reduced the stiffness of the fixation.
This study focuses on evaluating the failure resistance of a previously reduced tibia with internal fixation implants as PLate (PL) or InterMedullary Nail (IMN), subjected later to a tibial lateral trauma. To replicate this type of trauma, which can be caused by a road accident, a three-point bending test is considered using experimental tests and numerical simulations. The withstand evaluation of the tibia-PL and tibia-IMN structures was conducted by following the load transfer through, the bone and the used implants. The analysis, up to tibia failure, required the use of an elasto-plastic behavior law coupled to damage. The model parameters were identified using experimental tests. Il was shown that the tibia-IMN structure provided a bending resistant load up to three-times higher than the tibia-PL. In fact, the used screws for plate fixation induced a high level of stress in the vicinity of threaded region, leading to a crack initiation and a damage propagation. However, in tibia-IMN structure the highest stress was generated in the trapped zone between the loader and the nail, promoting crack formation. From a biomechanical point of view, the structure with IMN is safer than the structure with PL, whose fixation induces earlier damage in bone.
The evolutionary healing phenomenon of fractured tibia bone was investigated by comparing the bio-mechanical response of the human tibia following fracture fixation for two ranges of patient ages, when a body weight pressure (BWP) is applied. Three-dimensional finite element models have been developed by adopting the biomechanical characteristics of cortical and trabecular tibia bones, and considering the time-varying callus properties during the healing process for the two patients. The stress and strain levels generated within the fractured tibia bone by the screw tight fit during the assembly process revealed its dependence on the bone stiffness that degrades with age. They have an impact on primary stability of the implants prior to the osseointegration. The gap capacity to resist and allow a gradual BWP load transfer, through the callus for the tibia bone models, was analyzed. In fact, from 10 weeks after surgery, the callus allowed the BWP transfer for young patients, which guarantees sufficient structure stabilization of the fractured tibia. However, an insufficient load was transferred to the fracture gap for the old patient, even beyond 16 weeks, which delayed the bone consolidation.