Jamal Mansour

Dr. Jamal Mansour

orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

16Years (2011-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
21 April 2017 in Behavior Research Methods
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
JMJamal Mansour
Jamal Mansour
JBJ. L. Beaudry
J. L. Beaudry
RLR. C. L. Lindsay
R. C. L. Lindsay
Eyewitness identification experiments typically involve a single trial: A participant views an event and subsequently makes a lineup decision. As compared

1 December 2020 in Law and Human Behavior
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
JMJamal Mansour
Jamal Mansour
JBJennifer L. Beaudry
Jennifer L. Beaudry
MBMichelle I. Bertrand
Michelle I. Bertrand
NKNatalie Kalmet
Natalie Kalmet
EMElisabeth I. Melsom
Elisabeth I. Melsom
RLRoderick C. L. Lindsay
Roderick C. L. Lindsay
Prior research indicates disguise negatively affects lineup identifications but the mechanisms by which disguise works have not been explored and different disguises have not been compared. We investigated how two different types of disguise, four levels of varying degrees of coverage, and lineup type influence eyewitnesses' identification decisions, accuracy, and confidence. We predicted that identification accuracy would decrease as the disguise covered more of a perpetrator's face. We also predicted that type of disguise-stocking mask versus sunglasses and/or toque (i.e., knitted hat)-would influence identifications, but we had conflicting predictions about which disguise would impair their performance more. In two experiments (Ns = 87 and 91) we manipulated degree of coverage by two different types of disguise: a stocking mask or sunglasses and toque. Participants viewed mock-crime videos followed by simultaneous or sequential lineups. Disguise and lineup type did not interact. In support of the view that disguise prevents encoding, identification accuracy generally decreased with degree of disguise. For the stocking disguise, however, full and 2/3 coverage led to approximately the same rate of correct identifications-which suggests that disrupting encoding of specific features may be as detrimental as disrupting a whole face. Accuracy was most affected by sunglasses and we discuss the role meta-cognitions may have played. Lineup selections decreased more slowly than accuracy as coverage by disguise increased, indicating witnesses are insensitive to the effect of encoding conditions on accuracy. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2021 APA, all rights reserved).

1 March 2021 in Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
RHRuth Horry
Ruth Horry
RFRyan J. Fitzgerald
Ryan J. Fitzgerald
JMJamal Mansour
Jamal Mansour
When administering sequential lineups, researchers often inform their participants that only their first yes response will count. This instruction differs from the original sequential lineup protocol and from how sequential lineups are conducted in practice. Participants (N = 896) viewed a videotaped mock crime and viewed a simultaneous lineup, a sequential lineup with a first-yes-counts instruction, or a sequential control lineup (with no first-yes-counts instruction); the lineup was either target-present or target-absent. Participants in the first-yes-counts condition were less likely to identify the suspect and more likely to reject the lineup than participants in the simultaneous and sequential control conditions, suggesting a conservative criterion shift. The diagnostic value of suspect identifications, as measured by partial area under the curve, was lower in the first-yes-counts lineup than in the simultaneous lineup. Results were qualitatively similar for other metrics of diagnosticity, though the differences were not statistically significant. Differences between the simultaneous and sequential control lineups were negligible on all outcomes. The first-yes-counts instruction undermines sequential lineup performance and produces an artifactual simultaneous lineup advantage. Researchers should adhere to sequential lineup protocols that maximize diagnosticity and that would feasibly be implemented in practice, allowing them to draw more generalizable conclusions from their data. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2020 APA, all rights reserved).

1 June 2020 in Journal of Applied Research in Memory and Cognition
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
JMJamal Mansour
Jamal Mansour
Historically, researchers have collected eyewitness identification confidence using scales; however, in practice, eyewitnesses are more commonly asked for a verbal statement. In Experiment 1, participants viewed a simultaneous lineup and provided confidence in their own words, by explaining why they made their decision or by selecting from statements made by real eyewitnesses, and then provided a scale rating (0-100%) or provided only the scale rating. In Experiment 2, participants viewed a sequential lineup and provided confidence in their own words followed by the scale rating or provided only the scale rating. Confidence predicted identification accuracy in all conditions, although verbal statements were highly variable and challenging to interpret. For example, only when scale-based confidence was high (80%+) did interpretation of the verbal confidence statement reliably align with scale-based confidence. These data highlight the complexity of verbal confidence statements and the need to establish meaningful boundaries for interpreting verbal confidence statements.

1 June 2020 in Journal of Applied Research in Memory and Cognition
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
JMJamal Mansour
Jamal Mansour

19 March 2024 in Applied Cognitive Psychology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
PPPia Pennekamp
Pia Pennekamp
JMJamal Mansour
Jamal Mansour
RBRhiannon J. Batstone
Rhiannon J. Batstone
Typically, an eyewitness' verbal confidence is used to judge the reliability of their lineup identification. Across three experiments (N = 3976), we examined eyewitnesses' own words confidence in their lineup decision. For identification decisions (n = 1099), we identified 781 quantitatively unique responses representing 132 qualitatively unique statements that could be categorized into low, medium, and high confidence. For rejectors (n = 781), we identified 599 quantitatively unique responses representing 143 qualitatively unique responses that could be categorized into low, medium, and high confidence. Most participants provided a verbal phrase (e.g., pretty sure) but a significant proportion—34.19% of identifiers and 29.05% of rejectors—provided numbers (e.g., 80%). The present data highlight the variability in how confidence is expressed. The criminal justice system would benefit from guidance for interpreting verbal confidence. We provide a picture of eyewitnesses' verbal confidence as a first step.