Research has consistently shown that the instructional skills, or competencies, that teachers bring to the table influence the opportunities students have to learn. Teachers build those competencies over time, often through professional development (PD); however, they often cite PD as insufficient, in part because it can focus on the wrong competencies. In a series of focus groups, we systematically examined which teaching competencies teachers, teacher leaders, school administrators, and professional learning leaders identified as most critical for future PD efforts supporting K-8 mathematics and science teachers. In addition, we explored their stated rationales and their vision for how digital performance-based PD might support development of those competencies. Participants identified four competencies as most critical: (1) collaborative problem-based learning; (2) differentiation; (3) promoting engagement; and (4) eliciting student ideas. Rationales included ways in which they are essential for students, difficult to implement, and have insufficient support at present. Participants preferred the idea of digital and interactive role-playing PD over more traditional approaches, also citing the need for some agency in controlling the PD parameters and for the availability of rich feedback. Implications include the need for future research to incorporate stakeholder voice to close the gap between what is needed and what is provided and for follow-up studies to target a larger and more representative sample.
In this chapter, we argue for the value of teacher peer observations for professional learning. When peer observation happens in low stakes and collaborative settings, teachers may be more receptive to constructive feedback in contrast with feedback received as part of a summative evaluation, particularly when the teachers are provided with specific guidance on how to structure the feedback. In addition, teachers benefit from the process of being the observer (i.e., viewing other teachers’ classrooms and developing feedback statements) as a means of helping them better engage in self-assessment of their own practice. Time spent training on observational protocols is valuable professional development since training on the rubrics can help teachers internalize the characteristics of quality practice, and high scoring benchmark examples provide “expert models” to strive toward. Finally, with more available peers than coaches, the model is more scalable. We will illustrate some key ideas through an ongoing research study of a peer observation process and some of the emerging findings.