Long-gauge fiber optic sensors have proven to be valuable tools for structural health monitoring, especially in reinforced concrete (RC) beam structures. While their application in this area has been well-documented, their use in RC columns remains relatively unexplored. This suggests a promising avenue for further research and development. This paper presents a thorough comparison of long-gauge fiber optic sensors and traditional measurement tools when used to monitor RC columns under small eccentric compressive loading. The evaluation focuses on the stability and precision of each sensor type. A monitoring system was developed for laboratory testing to assess the performance of various sensor types under specific conditions. The system incorporated four measurement schemes, utilizing a combination of embedded and surface-mounted long-gauge fiber optic sensors, linear variable differential transformers (LVDTs), and point sensors (strain gauges). Long-gauge fiber optic sensors, securely mounted on the concrete surface near the tensile side, were found to accurately measure both large and small deformations, outperforming LVDTs. Compared to strain gauges and embedded optic sensors, the long-gauge fiber optic sensors demonstrated superior average strain measurement and minimal interference from protective covers.