Evaluating designed objects in real-world use cases enables usability optimization. For functional objects such as face masks, the mask must fit the user initially and continue to fit during movements such as talking. This paper describes methodology development for dynamic fit analysis of face masks using 3D head scans. Participants were scanned while wearing Basic, Cup, and Petal model masks before and after reading a passage aloud and completed surveys across eight fit dimensions. Face and mask measurements were virtually extracted from the head scans for quantitative fit analysis, and mask overlays were inspected for qualitative fit analysis. Four of eleven facial measurements changed significantly from closed to open-mouth posture while the nasal dorsum was identified as a stable landmark and served as a reference to define a mask shift metric. The mask shift was compared to the survey results for the model masks, with the Cup design fitting best and the Petal design rated as most comfortable. Poor fit modes identified from mask overlays were fabric buckling, compressed nose and ears, and gapping between the mask and facial features. This methodology can be implemented during the analysis stage of the iterative design process and complements static fit analyses.