Individuals’ decisions to promote or limit diversity in the workplace are ambivalent and may be influenced by their cognitive focus. Drawing from construal level theory, we test across five studies whether individuals are more supportive of diversity when diversity is thought of more abstractly versus concretely. Furthermore, we examined the salience of diversity pros and cons as the underlying mechanisms, as well as the role of egalitarian beliefs as a boundary condition for this discrepancy. We tested these hypotheses in five studies, which varied in samples, cognitive focus manipulation, and measures. Dutch and American individuals indicated more positive attitudes toward diversity (Studies 1 and 2) and made more choices that enhanced diversity (Studies 2 and 5) when they considered diversity abstractly (for most companies and teams) rather than concretely (for their own company and teams). Furthermore, the discrepancy in diversity attitudes by construal level was more pronounced among individuals with egalitarian beliefs (Study 3) and was driven by the heightened salience of diversity pros at more abstract versus concrete levels of construal (Study 4). This research contributes to further understanding the ambivalent view of diversity and provides concrete recommendations for diversity management in organizations.
7 April 2026 in Equality, Diversity and Inclusion: An International Journal
Purpose: While DEI practices aim to enhance the outcomes of disadvantaged groups, their impact remains uncertain, with disparities often persisting. This paper examines whether the accumulation of DEI practices helps reduce psychological and work disparities between employees, considering both their objective (e.g. gender and race) and subjective (or perceived) (dis)advantage. Design/methodology/approach: Study 1 surveyed 602 employees to assess the impact of perceiving their organization as having many or few DEI practices on their sense of inclusion and job satisfaction. Study 2 used an experimental design (N = 739) to extend the findings of Study 1 by manipulating the number of DEI practices. Findings: Study 1 showed that the effects of DEI practices on work experiences depended on gender and subjective disadvantage: more practices increased inclusion and job satisfaction for subjectively disadvantaged women but decreased them for subjectively disadvantaged men. Study 2, in which the number of DEI practices was manipulated again found that more DEI practices predicted worse anticipated outcomes for subjectively disadvantaged men. Study 2 also found that White participants, regardless of subjective disadvantage, had worse anticipated outcomes when there were more DEI practices. Originality/value: These studies emphasize the importance of both objective and subjective (dis)advantage in understanding the signaling effect of DEI practices, offering insights into designing policies that address group disparities in light of status dynamics.