Creative and critical thinking (C&CT) capabilities are essential qualities of future ready scientific literate citizens. As teacher educators, developing C&CT in science pre-service teachers (PSTs) requires supporting PSTs’ development of C&CT, in addition to supporting their understanding and capacity to teach for development of C&CT in their future school science students. In this study, four secondary science educators critically reflected on the development of our professional knowledge and practice for supporting secondary science PSTs’ understanding of, and capacity to teach, C&CT as future teachers of science. Meeting transcripts, reflective journaling and curriculum documents were inductively analysed for key themes, utilising an iterative approach with multiple cycles of review. Findings showed that integrating C&CT in explicit ways in our teaching and assessment tasks was not as straight-forward as initially imagined. Three themes were identified, showing how our thinking evolved, namely (1) becoming sensitised to C&CT in our science ITE practice; (2) developing a shared language and understanding for science education; and (3) illuminating the conditions for teaching C&CT. A recurring feature in all themes was the value of tensions for sensitising us to specific aspects of C&CT and its teaching. We offer recommendations for others seeking to develop science PSTs’ C&CT.
5 March 2022 in International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education
Reading, at its core, is a basic yet critical way to undertake learning and growth. This paper shares a professional learning and development initiative for science educators, which was underpinned by the popularity and premise of the reading group. In moving from simply being a vehicle for targeted discussion, the reading group facilitators sought to support the participants in taking a deeper dive into their practice with the impact ultimately being changes to their personal pedagogical content knowledge (PCK) for science. This small-scale qualitative study was informed by the voices of three science educators at different stages and career trajectories, who participated in interviews. The data revealed that their participation in the reading group informed the development of their personal and collective PCK by (a) creating conditions that encouraged meaningful links to be made between theory and practice, (b) encouraging the adoption of an inquiry stance as a means for engaging purposively with professional knowledge, and (c) initiating a transformation in their contemporary understandings of science and science education. By drawing on the participants’ narratives, this study brings to the fore both the simplicity and depth of complexity that can be achieved through a reading group focused on professional learning and development. The implications of this research are wide reaching as the reading group as a concept can be applied to a variety of contexts and shaped to reach a variety of educational needs.
26 August 2021 in Professional Development in Education
The vast literature on teacher professional development (PD) often assumes that the success of a PD programme should be measured by the extent to which the participating teachers accept and adopt, often in a relatively linear chain, the programme of learning, paying insufficient attention to how highly accomplished teachers respond to PD situations. This study investigated the experiences of a group of nine highly accomplished secondary school teachers, who also held leadership roles, following their participation in an intensive PD programme. Using an analytical lens of ‘acceptance barriers,’ we studied how these teachers interpreted their experiences of the programme and the impact of those experiences on their thinking and practice. Our findings show that teachers experienced the programme as a starting point, not a finished package. We identified a continuum of ways that these teachers applied, adapted and amplified ideas from the programme. We argue that recurring features of PD models such as linearity and implementation fidelity do not recognise teachers as professionals who assert agency over their own practice, and that the design, implementation and evaluation of PD programmes need to address how highly accomplished teachers are likely to respond, balancing fidelity with expectations of agency.
Contemporary views on physics education in high schools promote the need for students to develop their conceptual understanding about physics phenomena. However, teaching in this way requires specialized professional knowledge and for pre-service physics teachers, such knowledge needs to be scaffolded and developed. A strategy to support this knowledge development includes eliciting metacognition, where pre-service teachers have opportunities to explore and reconstruct their own knowledge, views, and attitudes about teaching physics. The conceptual understanding procedure (CUP) was developed in the late 1990s at Monash University, initially to support physics students in their first year at university. In particular, a CUP was used to support these students’ understanding of mechanics and highlight their potential alternate conceptions. Researchers found that two thirds of the students involved in this procedure reported that it had positive effects on their understanding and their ideas were clarified. In this paper, we investigate our own use of CUPs as physics teacher educators as a strategy to elicit metacognition with pre-service physics teachers to support their professional knowledge development. Our pre-service physics teachers act as high school physics students to complete the task, and then as physics teachers to explore the pedagogical purposes of the CUP. Ultimately, this process of working in these two roles, while reflecting on their immediate experiences, elicits metacognition in a meaningful way that scaffolds and supports the development of the specialized knowledge required for effective teaching. Thus, we recommend a CUP is a suitable and worthwhile pedagogical strategy to use when supporting pre-service physics teachers’ to elicit metacognition and support professional knowledge development to promote teaching for conceptual understanding.
A global shortage of qualified physics teachers requires some teachers to teach physics out-of-field (OOF). A concern for OOF physics teaching is that without appropriate physics content knowledge (CK), these teachers tend to focus on rote learning and may find it difficult to support students who require additional assistance or extension; they tend to teach in ways that do not foster conceptual understanding. This paper reports on research that investigated how content representations (CoRes) could be used to support OOF physics teachers’ knowledge for teaching electricity and magnetism. CoRes were used to elicit discussions between OOF and in-field physics teachers about important teaching and learning considerations (e.g. appropriate CK for students and appropriate instructional strategies for promoting conceptual understanding). Prior to engaging with CoRes, three OOF teachers were interviewed about teaching electricity and magnetism and their lessons during this topic were video recorded. Later, as these OOF teachers worked with their in-field colleagues using the CoRe framework, all discussions were audio recorded. To explore changes to the OOF teachers’ knowledge and practice from the CoRe process, they were interviewed and their follow-up electricity and magnetism lessons (for a different class) were video recorded. Findings showed that the CoRe processstimulated important discussions about teaching electricity and magnetism and considerations for students learning this topic. As a result, the OOF teachers developed their professional knowledge, including refinement of their CK, acquirement of new topic-specific instructional strategies, and more awareness of students’ understanding during lessons. This study concludes that CoRes are an effective strategy for supporting the professional learning of OOF physics teachers.