Charlotte L Brouwer

Dr. Charlotte L Brouwer

orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

15Years (2012-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
1 January 2020 in Radiotherapy and Oncology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
LDLisanne V. van Dijk
Lisanne V. van Dijk
LBLisa Van Den Bosch
Lisa Van Den Bosch
PAPaul Aljabar
Paul Aljabar
DPDevis Peressutti
Devis Peressutti
SBStefan Both
Stefan Both
CBCharlotte L Brouwer
Charlotte L Brouwer
Adequate head and neck (HN) organ-at-risk (OAR) delineation is crucial for HN radiotherapy and for investigating the relationships between radiation dose to OARs and radiation-induced side effects. The automatic contouring algorithms that are currently in clinical use, such as atlas-based contouring (ABAS), leave room for improvement. The aim of this study was to use a comprehensive evaluation methodology to investigate the performance of HN OAR auto-contouring when using deep learning contouring (DLC), compared to ABAS. The DLC neural network was trained on 589 HN cancer patients. DLC was compared to ABAS by providing each method with an independent validation cohort of 104 patients, which had also been manually contoured. For each of the 22 OAR contours - glandular, upper digestive tract and central nervous system (CNS)-related structures - the dice similarity coefficient (DICE), and absolute mean and max dose differences (|Δmean-dose| and |Δmax-dose|) performance measures were obtained. For a subset of 7 OARs, an evaluation of contouring time, inter-observer variation and subjective judgement was performed. DLC resulted in equal or significantly improved quantitative performance measures in 19 out of 22 OARs, compared to the ABAS (DICE/|Δmean dose|/|Δmax dose|: 0.59/4.2/4.1 Gy (ABAS); 0.74/1.1/0.8 Gy (DLC)). The improvements were mainly for the glandular and upper digestive tract OARs. DLC significantly reduced the delineation time for the inexperienced observer. The subjective evaluation showed that DLC contours were more often preferable to the ABAS contours overall, were considered to be more precise, and more often confused with manual contours. Manual contours still outperformed both DLC and ABAS; however, DLC results were within or bordering the inter-observer variability for the manual edited contours in this cohort. The DLC, trained on a large HN cancer patient cohort, outperformed the ABAS for the majority of HN OARs.

13 March 2012 in Radiation Oncology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
CBCharlotte L Brouwer
Charlotte L Brouwer
RSRoel J.H.M. Steenbakkers
Roel J.H.M. Steenbakkers
EHEdwin van Den Heuvel
Edwin van Den Heuvel
JDJoop C Duppen
Joop C Duppen
ANArash Navran
Arash Navran
AVAart A van 'T Veld
Aart A van 'T Veld
Consistent delineation of patient anatomy becomes increasingly important with the growing use of highly conformal and adaptive radiotherapy techniques. This study investigates the magnitude and 3D localization of interobserver variability of organs at risk (OARs) in the head and neck area with application of delineation guidelines, to establish measures to reduce current redundant variability in delineation practice.

1 June 2015 in Radiotherapy and Oncology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
CBCharlotte L Brouwer
Charlotte L Brouwer
RSRoel J.H.M. Steenbakkers
Roel J.H.M. Steenbakkers
JLJohannes A. Langendijk
Johannes A. Langendijk
NSNanna M. Sijtsema
Nanna M. Sijtsema
In the last decade, many efforts have been made to characterize anatomic changes of head and neck organs at risk (OARs) and the dosimetric consequences during radiotherapy. This review was undertaken to provide an overview of the magnitude and frequency of these effects, and to investigate whether we could find criteria to identify head and neck cancer patients who may benefit from adaptive radiotherapy (ART). Possible relationships between anatomic and dosimetric changes and outcome were explicitly considered. A literature search according to PRISMA guidelines was performed in MEDLINE and EMBASE for studies concerning anatomic or dosimetric changes of head and neck OARs during radiotherapy. Fifty-one eligible studies were found. The majority of papers reported on parotid gland (PG) anatomic and dosimetric changes. In some patients, PG mean dose differences between planning CT and repeat CT scans up to 10 Gy were reported. In other studies, only minor dosimetric effects (i.e. <1 Gy difference in PG mean dose) were observed as a result of significant anatomic changes. Only a few studies reported on the clinical relevance of anatomic and dosimetric changes in terms of complications or quality of life. Numerous potential selection criteria for anatomic and dosimetric changes during radiotherapy were found and listed. The heterogeneity between studies prevented unambiguous conclusions on how to identify patients who may benefit from ART in head and neck cancer. Potential pre-treatment selection criteria identified from this review include tumour location (nasopharyngeal carcinoma), age, body mass index, planned dose to the parotid glands, the initial parotid gland volume, and the overlap volume of the parotid glands with the target volume. These criteria should be further explored in well-designed and well-powered prospective studies, in which possible relationships between anatomic and dosimetric changes and outcome need to be established.

1 October 2020 in Physics and Imaging in Radiation Oncology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
CBCharlotte L Brouwer
Charlotte L Brouwer
ADAnna M. Dinkla
Anna M. Dinkla
LVLiesbeth Vandewinckele
Liesbeth Vandewinckele
WCWouter Crijns
Wouter Crijns
MCMichaël Claessens
Michaël Claessens
WEWouter van Elmpt
Wouter van Elmpt
The use of artificial intelligence (AI)/ machine learning (ML) applications in radiation oncology is emerging, however no clear guidelines on commissioning of ML-based applications exist. The purpose of this study was therefore to investigate the current use and needs to support implementation of ML-based applications in routine clinical practice. A survey was conducted among medical physicists in radiation oncology, consisting of four parts: clinical applications (1), model training, acceptance and commissioning (2), quality assurance (QA) in clinical practice and General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) (3), and need for education and guidelines (4). Survey answers of medical physicists of the same radiation oncology centre were treated as a separate unique responder in case reporting on different AI applications. In total, 213 medical physicists from 202 radiation oncology centres were included in the analysis. Sixty-nine percent (1 4 7) was using (37%) or preparing (32%) to use ML in clinic, mostly for contouring and treatment planning. In 86%, human observers were still involved in daily clinical use for quality check of the output of the ML algorithm. Knowledge on ethics, legislation and data sharing was limited and scattered among responders. Besides the need for (implementation) guidelines, training of medical physicists and larger databases containing multicentre data was found to be the top priority to accommodate the further introduction of ML in clinical practice. The results of this survey indicated the need for education and guidelines on the implementation and quality assurance of ML-based applications to benefit clinical introduction.

1 July 2016 in Radiotherapy and Oncology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
CBCharlotte L Brouwer
Charlotte L Brouwer
RSRoel J.H.M. Steenbakkers
Roel J.H.M. Steenbakkers
Arjen Van der SchaafArjen Van der Schaaf
Arjen Van der Schaaf
CSChantal T.C. Sopacua
Chantal T.C. Sopacua
LDLisanne V. van Dijk
Lisanne V. van Dijk
NSNanna M. Sijtsema
Nanna M. Sijtsema
The aim of this study was to develop and validate a method to select head and neck cancer patients for adaptive radiotherapy (ART) pre-treatment. Potential pre-treatment selection criteria presented in recent literature were included in the analysis. Deviations from the planned parotid gland mean dose (PG ΔDmean) were estimated for 113 head and neck cancer patients by re-calculating plans on repeat CT scans. Uni- and multivariable linear regression analyses were performed to select pre-treatment parameters, and ROC curve analysis was used to determine cut off values, for selecting patients with a PG dose deviation larger than 3Gy. The patient selection method was validated in a second patient cohort of 43 patients. After multivariable analysis, the planned PG Dmean remained the only significant parameter for PG ΔDmean. A sensitivity of 91% and 80% could be obtained using a threshold of PG Dmean of 22.2Gy, for the development and validation cohorts, respectively. This would spare 38% (development cohort) and 24% (validation cohort) of patients from the labour-intensive ART procedure. The presented method to select patients for ART pre-treatment reduces the labour of ART, contributing to a more effective allocation of the department resources.

1 October 2020 in Physics and Imaging in Radiation Oncology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
CBCharlotte L Brouwer
Charlotte L Brouwer
DBDjamal Boukerroui
Djamal Boukerroui
JOJorge Oliveira
Jorge Oliveira
PLPadraig Looney
Padraig Looney
RSRoel J.H.M. Steenbakkers
Roel J.H.M. Steenbakkers
MGMark J. Gooding
Mark J. Gooding
Auto-contouring performance has been widely studied in development and commissioning studies in radiotherapy, and its impact on clinical workflow assessed in that context. This study aimed to evaluate the manual adjustment of auto-contouring in routine clinical practice and to identify improvements regarding the auto-contouring model and clinical user interaction, to improve the efficiency of auto-contouring. A total of 103 clinical head and neck cancer cases, contoured using a commercial deep-learning contouring system and subsequently checked and edited for clinical use were retrospectively taken from clinical data over a twelve-month period (April 2019–April 2020). The amount of adjustment performed was calculated, and all cases were registered to a common reference frame for assessment purposes. The median, 10th and 90th percentile of adjustment were calculated and displayed using 3D renderings of structures to visually assess systematic and random adjustment. Results were also compared to inter-observer variation reported previously. Assessment was performed for both the whole structures and for regional sub-structures, and according to the radiation therapy technologist (RTT) who edited the contour. The median amount of adjustment was low for all structures (<2 mm), although large local adjustment was observed for some structures. The median was systematically greater or equal to zero, indicating that the auto-contouring tends to under-segment the desired contour. Auto-contouring performance assessment in routine clinical practice has identified systematic improvements required technically, but also highlighted the need for continued RTT training to ensure adherence to guidelines.