Selecting donor organs is both a science and an art. The calculus is often complex evaluating recipients’ acute needs and the quality and risks of the donor organs. Sarcoidosis is usually a disease of exclusion and considered an idiopathic inflammatory granulomatous process frequently in the lung but often with multiorgan involvement. New insights into the interplay between the environmental or occupational antigens and the susceptible genetic host in sarcoidosis have come to light. One such occupational antigen with mixed data regarding the risk of developing sarcoidosis after exposure is silica dust. Despite strict exposure limitations enforced in the United States and several other governing bodies worldwide, clusters of silicosis are on the rise due to engineered stone (quartz), which contain silica particles that when cut can create a dust that can exceed exposure limitations. Data on the quartz-sarcoidosis relationship is minimal, and thus questions exist regarding the risk of silica dust exposure and the risk of sarcoidosis. Silicosis tends to only affect the lungs, preventing them usually from being transplanted while sarcoidosis is recognized as having a high probability of multiple organ involvement. An index case discovered during organ recovery highlights the possible association between silica exposure and sarcoidosis. This case also examples the complexity of donor organ evaluation and the challenges in organ procurement from exposed individuals.