During the Pleistocene glacial periods, the ranges of many temperate species in Europe contracted southwards to refugia near the Mediterranean Basin. This study tested the ‘expansion–contraction’ model by applying the ecological niche modelling approach to one widespread temperate tree species, pedunculate oak, Quercus robur L., distributed across Europe and Anatolia. We projected the distribution of Q. robur under climatic conditions of the Present, the mid-Holocene [HOL, c. 6000 years before present (YBP)], the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM, c. 22000 YBP) and the Last Interglacial (LIG, c. 130000 YBP). Quercus robur was at equilibrium with the climate as the model prediction was highly compatible with the its known distribution range under present bioclimatic conditions. The LIG and the HOL predictions gave a much broader distribution range than that during the LGM, suggesting its range contracted towards favourable areas in southern Europe and Anatolia. The results indicate that the glacial refugia hypothesis, based mainly on the ‘expansion–contraction’ model, applies to Q. robur, although possible extra-Mediterranean refugia in northern, western and southern France are also identified. This study therefore supports claims that European biogeography is significantly more complex than previously thought.
12 October 2012 in Biological Journal of the Linnean Society
One of the fundamental goals of phylogeographical studies should be to achieve a comprehensive geographical sampling of any investigated group. In this study, we conducted the most comprehensive geographical investigation to date for the great spotted woodpecker complex (Dendrocopos major), including populations from North Africa and Eurasia [including specimens from China, Japan and southern Caucasia (Anatolia, Azerbaijan and Iran)], in order to evaluate its genetic structure and population history. At the same time, we tested species limits within the D. major complex, which currently includes 14 recognized subspecies based on morphology and coloration. We based our study on haplotypes for the mitochondrial gene NADH dehydrogenase subunit 2 (ND2). Most haplotypes were obtained from museum toe pads, although we also used some previously published data. We also tested gene flow through MDIV, and estimated divergence dates among lineages using BEAST. The analysis of 352 base pairs of the ND2 gene from 155 individuals sampled from 33 populations showed significant phylogeographical structure across the breeding range. Our results found four distinct and reciprocally monophyletic clades: China, Japan, Iran–Azerbaijan and Eurasia–North Africa, with no phylogeographical structure within them. Coalescent-based gene flow analysis showed restricted gene flow between China and Japan and between Japan and Eurasia. On the basis of the gene flow and phylogenetic analysis results, we propose the recognition of at least four different species within the complex. We also propose that, within the Eurasia–North Africa clade, a rapid population expansion through ‘leading edge expansion’ from refugia in Iberia, Kursk and North Africa, as well as irruptive and loop migration, can explain the lack of phylogeographical structure.
Measurement error in morphological characters is an important issue for many ornithological studies (e.g. ecomorphology, quantitative studies of heritability, studies of systematic and geographic variation). The variation in external morphological characters, such as wing and tarsus length, is usually evaluated using multivariate statistical methods such as principal component analysis (PCA). These are often considered better than univariate statistical methods for explaining size and shape variation in bird populations because they reduce the ‘dimensionality’ of the data — the size of individual measures (wing etc.) are assumed to contain a component reflecting a general character ‘size’. However, the effect of measurement error on principal components has not been formally assessed with respect to such data. Here we report three examples in order to assess the importance of measurement error for analyses within and between bird populations. The effect of measurement error on PCA is also discussed in relation to the importance of levels of error in shape components. Our results indicate that, in relation to size (PC1), principal component scores are affected less by measurement error if the covariance matrix is used rather than the correlation matrix. However, the effects of relative measurement error were substantially greater in subsequent axes, which represent shape variation rather than size, than they were in the size axis (PC1). Measurement error may, therefore, be a more important issue for shape axes than for the size axis and this problem may be exacerbated further if very few characters are used in the PCA. Our results also indicate that PCA is especially sensitive to issues relating to sample size. We recommend that if reducing the measurement error in size and shape measures is not possible, and the sample size is small (≤ 30), principal component scores should be derived using the covariance matrix, as these are more likely to give more robust results.
In this study, we re-evaluated historical demography of the Eurasian green woodpecker (Picus viridis) on the basis of previously published multi-locus mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) data and ecological niche modelling. We particularly aimed to test glacial refugia hypothesis during climatic oscillations of the late Quaternary for the Eurasian green woodpecker. Our results indicate that the Eurasian green woodpecker was sensitive to the effects of climate change. Prior to the Last Glacial Maximum (22000 years ago), the population contraction started and the Eurasian green woodpecker restricted its range to southern Europe (including France), Anatolia, and the Caucasus/Caspian region, and, afterwards, substantially expanded its range from this restricted area to its present range around 14500 years before present. Therefore, during the Last Glacial Maximum, we recognize a single large refugium for this species, located in southern Europe (including France), Anatolia, and the Caucasus/Caspian region.