A previous genome-wide association study (GWAS) in colorectal cancer (CRC) patients with gastric and/or prostate cancer in their families suggested genetic loci with a shared risk for these three cancers. A second haplotype GWAS was undertaken in the same colorectal cancer patients and different controls with the aim of confirming the result and finding novel loci. The haplotype GWAS analysis involved 685 patients with colorectal cancer cases and 1642 healthy controls from Sweden. A logistic regression model was used with a sliding window haplotype approach. Whole-genome and exome sequencing datawere used to find candidate SNPs to be tested in a nested case-control study. In the analysis of 685 colorectal cancer cases and 1642 controls, all ten candidate loci from the previous study were confirmed. Fifty candidate loci were suggested with a p-value < 5 × 10⁻⁶ and odds ratios between 1.35–6.52. Two of the 50 loci, on 13q33.3 and 16q23.3, were the same as in the previous study. Whole-genome or exome data from 122 colorectal cancer patients was used to search for candidate variants in these 50 loci. A nested case-control study was performed to test genetic variants at 11 loci in a cohort of 827 familial colorectal cancer and a sub-cohort of 293 familial CRC cases with colorectal, gastric, and/or prostate cancer within their families and 1530 healthy controls. One SNP, rs115943733 on 10q11.21, reached statistical significance (OR = 3.26, p = 0.009). Seven SNPs in 4 loci had a higher OR in the smaller cohort compared to the larger study CRC cases. The results in this GWAS gave support for suggested loci with an increased shared risk of CRC, gastric, and/or prostate cancer. Further studies are needed to confirm the shared risk to be able to use this information in cancer prevention.