Against the prevailing outcomes-based education and the instrumentalization of education, a movement has arisen towards holistic education. This aims to go beyond objective measurement of the outcomes of education in order to treat the student as a whole person. In this paper, we shall examine some strands of education in Japan which in some way or another feature the idea of the whole person. This includes the tradition of clinical pedagogy, which originated in Kyoto University, Yukichi Shitahodo’s educational anthropology (Kyoiku-Ningengaku), Kuniyoshi Obara’s Zenjin Education (the education of the whole person) and holistic education. Notwithstanding the fact that such education is benevolent in intention, it can be miseducative in some respects. In the light of this, and with some reference to criticism of the idea of the whole person, we shall point to an alternative vision of education of the whole person following Cavell’s Emersonian moral perfectionism – a perfectionism that is thoroughly anti-foundationalist and that transcends self-entrapment in circulatory discourse on the whole. In critical dialogue between the rich traditions of Japanese thought and the critical voice of liberalism raised from within the West, we hope to find a more nuanced answer to the question of how being a whole might make sense.
In this chapter Naoko Saito explores the prophetic dimension in Cavell's idea of philosophy as the education of grownups, which she interprets in terms of the necessity of the renewal of the self and language. The idea of mutual education is examined in the light of the apparent tension it raises between self-cultivation and the need for the other. Taking its lead from Cavell's politics of interpretation, the chapter eases this tension by demonstrating the intricate relation between initiation into and departure from one's language community. It is in Emerson's assertion that “A man should learn to detect and watch that gleam of light which flashes from his mind from within” that Saito finds her title phrase and from which she draws the idea of the other as teacher attesting to the prophetic renewal of language. This opens a path from the inmost to the outmost, demonstrating the inseparability of democracy and education. In the course of her discussion, she is at pains to stress Emerson's American voice and hence to evoke the idea of a democracy always still to come.
23 March 2018 in Journal of Philosophy of Education
The 15th Biennial Meeting of the International Network of Philosophers of Education (INPE) was held from 17 to 20 August 2016, at the University of Warsaw. The conference theme was ‘Philosophy as Translation and the Understanding of Other Cultures’, and we take this as the title for this Special Issue of Ethics and Education. The articles included in this volume are representative of the dynamism of the conference, reflecting a diversity of initiatives and interventions in what might be thought of as a process of mutual education among all the participants. This, we believe, is the product of the experience of translation: translation as a linguistic experience inseparable from human transformation, which involves the crossing of borders. The way they intersect and diverge itself embodies the processes and the product of translation played out in the conference.
28 December 2021 in Educational Philosophy and Theory
Morimichi KatoTohoku University, JapanThe introduction of modern (Western) education in Japan was an inevitable consequence of the contact with the Great Powers of the West. This contact is symboli...