This study is the first of its kind to diachronically analyze how the use of language surrounding anxiety has changed in each version of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM). Using corpus linguistic technology, the collocations of the word “anxiety” were analyzed and ranked using log dice to determine the strength of associations both within and across each version of this clinical guide. The results demonstrate that collocations among anxiety are changing with each published manual. In addition, specific diagnoses (i.e., generalized anxiety, separation anxiety, and panic disorder) are in flux over time. Lastly, the interpersonal language associated with anxiety is changing, leading to implications for both researchers and clinicians in the field of mental health.
Background/Objectives: This study examines the academic discourse surrounding Critical Incident Stress Debriefing (CISD) and Critical Incident Stress Management (CISM) for first responders using Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA) topic modeling. It aims to uncover latent topical structures in the literature and critically evaluate assumptions to identify gaps and limitations. Methods: A corpus of 214 research article abstracts related to CISD/M was gathered from the Web of Science Core Collection. After preprocessing, we used Orange Data Mining software’s LDA tool to analyze the corpus. We tested models ranging from 2 to 10 topics. To guide interpretation and labeling, we evaluated them using log perplexity, topic coherence, and LDAvis visualizations. A four-topic model offered the best balance of detail and interpretability. Results: Four topics emerged: (1) Critical Incident Stress Management in medical and emergency settings, (2) psychological and group-based interventions for PTSD and trauma, (3) peer support and experiences of emergency and military personnel, and (4) mental health interventions for first responders. Key gaps included limited focus on cumulative trauma, insufficient longitudinal research, and variability in procedural adherence affecting outcomes. Conclusions: The findings highlight the need for CISD/M protocols to move beyond event-specific interventions and address cumulative stressors. Recommendations include incorporating holistic, proactive mental health strategies and conducting longitudinal studies to evaluate long-term effectiveness. These insights can help refine CISD/M approaches and enhance their impact on first responders working in high-stress environments.
Corpus linguistics is a growing field of analysis in the medical field, but despite its analytic abilities, it has yet to be utilized on psychiatry’s chief text, the DSM. This study utilizes a diachronic corpus linguistics approach to examine changes in the personality disorders sections of the various editions of the DSM. The analysis reveals that there is actually little linguistic change in the DSM from its inception to the most recent version. These findings have implications for how practitioners and educators think about, use, and teach the DSM and may impact future versions of the DSM.
The substance use treatment field relies heavily on the DSM as its guide to diagnosis of substance use disorders, yet many are unaware of the history of the DSM and how it has changed over time. This study utilized a diachronic corpus linguistics approach to study the substance use subsections of both the diagnostic manuals that served as the precursors to the DSM as well as the various editions of the DSM. The results show that while the overall size of the substance use sections has increased drastically, their word use frequency has not changed. This has implications for how substance use disorders are taught, how clinicians diagnose, and how future versions of the DSM might look.
The substance use treatment field relies heavily on the DSM as its guide to diagnosis of substance use disorders, yet many are unaware of the history of the DSM and how it has changed over time. This study utilized a diachronic corpus linguistics approach to study the substance use subsections of both the diagnostic manuals that served as the precursors to the DSM as well as the various editions of the DSM. The results show that while the overall size of the substance use sections has increased drastically, their word use frequency has not changed. This has implications for how substance use disorders are taught, how clinicians diagnose, and how future versions of the DSM might look.