The poor initial resilience of the ground-breaking Brazilian urban social housing programme ‘Minha Casa, Minha Vida’(MCMV) affects millions of people, who have tried to adapt their homes, survived the unexpected and have to reinvent themselves constantly. This study delimits the elements that compose the concept of resilience, namely: the impacts, vulnerabilities and adaptive capacities that characterize the resilience of the built environment in the case study selected. To achieve these aims, advanced Post-Occupancy Evaluation (POE) and Co-production techniques have been applied in the case study of a typical Brazilian MCMV development in Uberlandia (Brazil). The results highlighted factors going beyond the typical vulnerabilities already seen in most of these developments. They pointed out the adaptive recovery capacities as key factors for resilience. This case study provides the means to investigate resilience and its variables in depth within the specific context of MCMV’s social housing, subsidising designers and public policies makers in the elaboration of more resilient projects for these social housing communities.
Resumo Este artigo deriva de pesquisa de mestrado que teve como objetivo analisar a resiliência no ambiente construído de habitações de interesse social (HIS) do Programa Minha Casa, Minha Vida, com enfoque em dois de seus atributos: adequação climática e adequação ambiental. Para isso, foram desenvolvidos procedimentos metodológicos de avaliação pós-ocupação para observação desses atributos em HIS situadas no estudo de caso intitulado Residencial Sucesso Brasil (Uberlândia, MG). O artigo dá enfoque à descrição dos resultados que caracterizaram a inadequação ambiental do estudo de caso elencado. Trata-se de características inerentes ao empreendimento entregue que ocasionam, dentre outros efeitos, o desperdício de materiais construtivos, altos gastos com energia elétrica e a depredação de áreas recreacionais e áreas de preservação permanente (APP). Como principal contribuição do trabalho, destaca-se a identificação de soluções projetuais que devem ser encorajadas em projeto de HIS, a fim de amplificar sua adequação ambiental. Ademais, os resultados da pesquisa desenvolvida amparam a obtenção de HIS mais resilientes, alinhando-se, assim, aos objetivos de agendas urbanas de relevância internacional, que colocam a resiliência como motor no combate à vulnerabilidade das grandes cidades.
The COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted aspects that require greater attention in residential buildings, especially in social housing developments. For example, thermal comfort and air renewal, play an important role in the environmental quality of housing and control of spreading pathogens, including coronavirus. The challenge is adequately providing these attributes in Brazilian social housing (SH) as naturally ventilated buildings where predominantly low-income families live. Considering it, a study was developed using computational simulation to evaluate the interaction between the indicators of thermal comfort (using the adaptive model) and air renewal (in air changes per hour - ACH) in a horizontal semi-detached typology of social housing provided by the Brazilian government program Minha Casa, Minha Vida, located in Uberlândia city, Minas Gerais state, Brazil. Ventilated roofs, variable window opening patterns, effective ventilation areas, and horizontal window shadings were the behavioral and physical interventions suggested to comparative analyses according to their performance to the indicators. The paper aims to present and discuss the main results obtained in terms of positive trends for the analyzed indicators’ performance and for the typology and location studied, seeking the achievement of better ventilated and thermally comfortable habitats. Additionally, a brief study on the most appropriate adaptive thermal comfort model for studies in the city of Uberlândia is presented, contributing to the future performance of more accurate thermal comfort analyses in SH, aiming at more assertive and resilient provision of guidances for renovations.
Urban transformations have intensified the negative impacts of climate change on vulnerable communities. Social housing (SH) provided by the Brazilian programme Minha Casa, Minha Vida (MCMV) faces challenges with thermal stress and unsanitary conditions due to climatic inadequacies. Additionally, self-built expansions exacerbate these issues by limiting natural ventilation and solar access, leading to thermal discomfort, increased energy consumption and health risks. This study utilized post-occupancy evaluation (POE) techniques, including questionnaires, morphological analyses, walkthroughs and computational simulations to assess the impact of unassisted expansions on thermal comfort and air renewal in Brazilian horizontal SH developments located at Uberlândia city, Minas Gerais state. Findings indicated that 81.05% of participant dwellers experienced heat discomfort, with 43.17% finding ventilation inadequate. Furthermore, indoor thermal discomfort was 15.78% in average higher than outdoor conditions, and air renewal in expanded units was on average 14.9% poorer compared to non-expanded ones. These results underscored the substandard thermal environment quality of horizontal SH units in use, increasing understanding on the correlation between unassisted expansions and their impact on environmental quality. The research benefits from the loop of learning provided by POE instruments performance, providing insights for targeted interventions aimed at improving climate resilience and overall living conditions.
Social Housing (SH) provided by the Brazilian Minha Casa, Minha Vida (MCMV) program often exposes residents to thermal stress and poor living conditions due to inadequate adaptation to the local climate. Self-built renovations that increase housing density exacerbate these issues by restricting natural ventilation and solar radiation, which in turn heightens thermal discomfort, energy demands, and health problems. This paper presents a climate resilience assessment of horizontal SH units from the MCMV program using the Resilience Ruler (RR), a Post-Occupancy Evaluation (POE) tool that measures resilience based on users' thermal comfort on a scale from 1 (not resilient) to 5 (very resilient). Conducted in a mixed and dry climate zone, represented by the city of Uberlândia, MG, Brazil, the analysis revealed an average resilience score of 2 (little resilience) for bioclimatic design and residents' climatic adaptability, highlighting priority areas for intervention. The study expands the understanding of the relationship between modifications in horizontal SH and climate resilience based on human thermal comfort. Furthermore, it provides renovation guidelines aimed at strengthening climate resilience in housing, making relevant contributions to Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) 11 and 13. The research reinforces the importance of methodologies such as POE in supporting more effective design and management practices in SH, particularly in the face of global climate change challenges.