Simulations and virtual or remote laboratories are increasingly used in schools. The extent to which individual experimental skills can be acquired when experimenting in digital applications is, however, questionable. This paper focuses on finding multimedia features for digital experiments to support the transfer of measured values from the laboratory system to a diagram. Beside physical considerations, spatial translation processes could be crucial for a successful assignment. Therefore, the influence of the subjects’ spatial ability is examined. Using a pretest post-test design (), the effects of training with supportive animation (animation group) and training with an interactive task and feedback (interactive group) were tested. The results of both groups were each compared to those of a reference group. Eye tracking data were recorded during training to investigate the origin of different training effects. Hence, fixations and saccades during training were analyzed. For the investigation of the distribution of the saccadic movements, polar diagrams were used in combination with estimated probability density functions. The results show that the score in the pretest is correlated to the score achieved in the card rotation test, which measures the spatial rotation skills of the subjects. Further, the subjects in the interactive group benefited from the training more than the subjects in the reference group did. There were no significant differences in the effect of the training between the animation group and the reference group. Eye tracking data reveal that the training in the interactive group caused the most comparative eye movements between the laboratory system and the diagram. The training in the animation group led to the highest visual attention; however, subjects in this group concentrated on the dynamic elements. These results indicate that especially students with weak spatial skills need additional support when transferring measured values from the laboratory system to the diagram. This assignment can be practiced in computer-based experiments, in particular with an interactive training task and feedback. Additionally, the analysis showed that the training is equally suitable for learners with different spatial abilities. A corresponding task was implemented into a virtual laboratory.
Zusammenfassung: Lernende haben oft Schwierigkeiten, Informationen aus visuellen, dynamischen Lernmedien zu extrahieren. Daher werden diese häufig durch Hinweise ergänzt, welche die visuelle Aufmerksamkeit steuern und den Lernerfolg verbessern können.Bisher ist offen, wie gut der Lernerfolg beim Lernen mit Videos in Abhängigkeit von der Hinweismodalität vorhergesagt werden kann und welche Rolle dabei die visuelle Aufmerksamkeit spielt. Das Ziel dieser Studie ist, die Hinweismodalität zu variieren, um den Lernerfolg zu beeinflussen und dabei zu untersuchen, wie viel der so erzeugten Varianzen im Lernerfolg durch die visuelle Aufmerksamkeit erklärt werden können.Dazu wurden zwei Videos von Wirbelstromexperimenten erstellt und mit Hinweisen versehen, die entweder visuell als Kombination aus Textfeldern und Spotlights oder auditiv als gesprochener Text implementiert waren. 40 Lehramtsstudierende wurden zufällig der visuellen oder auditiven Bedingung zugeteilt. Ein Eye-Tracker zeichnete die Blickbewegungen auf. Die Vor- und Nachtestung erfolgte durch Fragebögen, die affektive und kognitive Lernfaktoren erfassten.Verglichen mit Textfeldern und Spotlights führten gesprochene Hinweise zu einer höheren visuellen Aufmerksamkeit und zu besseren Lernergebnissen. Allerdings förderten Textfelder und Spotlights die Anwendung der Fachsprache besser als gesprochene Hinweise. Bemerkenswert dabei ist, dass die visuelle Aufmerksamkeit bei den Lernergebnissen auf das durch den gesprochenen Hinweis adressierte Experiment und somit auf das Videomaterial bezogen war. Im Gegensatz dazu war beim Erwerb der Fachtermini die visuelle Aufmerksamkeit auf die Textfelder und somit auf die Hinweise ausschlaggebend.Aus den Ergebnissen lässt sich für die Gestaltung von Demonstrationsvideos ableiten, dass die Hinweismodalität auf die Lernziele abgestimmt werden sollte.
Qualitative experiments such as visualizing magnetostatic fields with iron filings are often carried out in primary and secondary school, while quantitative evaluations of permanent magnetic fields are often left aside. This also applies to most lectures at university despite the fact that the topic would fit quite well into a lecture on electrodynamics. Gaining a quantitative picture of permanent magnetic fields is a rather difficult task. Calculating such fields often requires numerical methods and measuring them a very sensitive apparatus. However, as magnetic fields are invisible, properties of these fields have to be determined in order to visualize them quantitatively. A remote laboratory was developed to be used in teaching at the Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München. It combines exact measurements and theoretical predictions for the field of a cylindrical permanent magnet. Furthermore, multiple representations of the measurements and possibilities of analysis are offered. The laboratory is accessible via http://www.didaktik.physik.uni-muenchen.de/sims/magneticfield/
5 June 2024 in Physical Review Physics Education Research
Vector fields are a highly abstract physical concept that is often taught using visualizations. Although vector representations are particularly suitable for visualizing quantitative data, they are often confusing, especially when describing real fields such as magnetic and electric fields, as the vector arrows can overlap. The present study investigates vector understanding at the end of secondary education. In particular, the extent to which the geometry of the field can be derived from conventional unit vector representations and representations with centered unit vectors was examined. To support this understanding, two exercises were compared. The unirepresentational exercise argued within the conventional unit vector representation, while the multirepresentational exercise attempted to support the link between centered and conventional unit vectors. The results show that almost all test subjects solved the items for generating vector representations correctly, but significant difficulties were encountered in interpreting vector representations. Drawing and interpreting vector representations therefore appear to be different skills that should be practiced intensively and in an integrated way. Various problems could be identified when interpreting vector representations. For example, the number of vectors is often erroneously used to estimate the strength of the field, although more vectors per surface element actually only increase the resolution of the representation. Here, however, the results suggest that the longitudinal density and the transverse density of the drawn vectors are perceived differently by the learners. Furthermore, the learners recognized the field’s geometry much more readily from centered unit vectors than from conventional unit vectors. Errors occur especially when interpreting the geometry of conventional unit vector representations of rotational fields and fields containing both sources and sinks while the geometries of fields containing only sinks were interpreted quite well. The comparison between the two training exercises showed that a promising approach to deepen students’ understanding would be to use an exercise that contrasts conventional and centered unit vector representations and explains how to translate from one representation to the other, rather than describing the main elements of only a single representation. Finally, based on the results of the study, we propose a strategy for teaching vector representations in schools. Given the significantly improved readability of the representation with centered unit vectors, the results even raise the question of whether this type of representation could possibly replace the conventional representation in textbooks and learning materials in the future. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
So far, there have only been a few articles in this column that discussed diffraction or augmented reality (AR) enhancements. In this article, we want to bring both aspects together and describe an experiment that can be used to investigate diffraction phenomena with low-cost materials and augmented reality in the classroom. Diffraction experiments in schools often have (at least) two difficulties:
Previous research has shown that inquiry-based learning through hands-on experiments, as well as learning with multiple, external representations (MERs) can promote the understanding of complex phenomena in physics. In this context, augmented reality (AR) smartglasses make it possible to superimpose real experiments with virtually presented information while maintaining learners’ freedom to interact with the experimental setup. This allows spatial and temporal contiguity to be established between the phenomenon and the supporting virtual visualizations which can help to reduce learners' cognitive load and to free up cognitive resources for learning. We introduce an AR learning environment for the investigation of the Lorentz force. By visualizing the fields relevant to the experiment in AR, the newly developed experiment presented in this paper aims to enable learners to investigate the physical phenomenon more directly. Additionally, this setup can foster the acquisition of representational skills by providing the possibility to superimpose fields using various representations. Beside the theory-driven design of setup and learning environment this work also describes the physical background and calculational tools that are necessary to produce accurate visualizations of the fields in three dimensions. The presented learning setting will be used in future studies to investigate how MERs should be combined in a guided inquiry-based learning environment to best promote learners' conceptual knowledge and representational skills. We present the system and report usability data that were collected from a sample of 188 secondary school students. The average score was 80.18 (SD: 12.06), which signals an excellent usability of the AR learning environment, laying the foundation for further investigations into the learning process with the application in the future.