Purpose: Although the Net Promoter Score (NPS) index is simple, NPS has weaknesses that make NPS's interpretation misleading. The main criticism is that identical index values can correspond to different levels of customer loyalty. This makes difficult to determine whether the company is improving/deteriorating in two different years. The authors describe the application of statistical tools to establish whether identical values may/may not be considered similar under statistical hypotheses.Design/methodology/approach: Equal NPSs with a “similar” component composition should have a two-way table satisfying marginal homogeneity hypothesis. The authors compare the marginals using a cumulative marginal logit model that assumes a proportional odds structure: the model has the same effect for each logit. Marginal homogeneity corresponds to null effect. If the marginal homogeneity hypothesis is rejected, the cumulative odds ratio becomes a tool for measuring the proportionality between the odds.Findings: The authors propose an algorithm that helps managers in their decision-making process. The authors' methodology provides a statistical tool to recognize customer base compositions. The authors suggest a statistical test of the marginal distribution homogeneity of the table representing the index compositions at two times. Through the calculation of cumulative odds ratios, the authors discriminate against the hypothesis of equality of the NPS.Originality/value: The authors' contribution provides a statistical alternative that can be easily implemented by business operators to fill the known shortcomings of the index in the customer satisfaction's context. This paper confirms that although a single number summarizes and communicates a complex situation very quickly, the number is ambiguous and unreliable if not accompanied by other tools.
27 January 2014 in Communications in Statistics - Theory and Methods
We introduce a new definition of generalized marginal interactions, called marginal nested interactions, which includes baseline, local, continuation and reverse continuation logits and odds ratios as special cases. The significant aspect of this definition is the inclusion of new types of logits and odds ratios that can handle non-ordinal, ordinal and partially ordered categorical variables in a flexible and appropriate way. It is proved also that the marginal nested interactions define a saturated model of a multi-way contingency table.
The change-point model is an established methodology for the construction of self-starting control charts. Change-point charts are often nonparametric in order to be independent from any specific assumptions about the process distribution. Nonetheless, this methodology is usually implemented by considering all possible splits of a given stream of observations into two adjacent sub-samples. This can make the recent observations too influential and the chart’s signals too dependent on limited evidence. This paper proposes to correct such a distortion by using a window approach, which forces the use of only comparisons based on sub-samples of the same size. The resulting charts are “omnibus”, with respect to their having any kind of shift and also any direction of such shifts. To prove this, this paper focuses on a chart based on the Cramér–von Mises test. We report a simulation study evaluating the average number of readings to obtain a signal after a known shift has occurred. We conclude that, beyond being stable with respect to the direction of the shift, the new chart overcomes its competitors when the distribution heads toward regularity. Finally, the new approach is shown to have successful application to a real problem about air quality.
In this work we handle with categorical (ordinal) variables and we focus on the (in)dependence relationship under the marginal, conditional and context-specific perspective. If the first two are well known, the last one concerns independencies holding only in a subspace of the outcome space. We take advantage from the Hierarchical Multinomial Marginal models and provide several original results about the representation of context-specific independencies through these models. By considering the graphical aspect, we take advantage from the chain graphical models. The resultant graphical model is a so-called "stratified" chain graphical model with labelled arcs. New Markov properties are provided. Furthermore, we consider the graphical models under the regression poit of view. Here we provide simplification of the regression parameters due to the context-specific independencies. Finally, an application about the innovation degree of the Italian enterprises is provided.