Habitus plays a crucial part in Bourdieu's theory of sociocultural reproduction for understanding the persistence of inequalities in the education system. According to Bourdieu, students from homes that are heavily equipped with cultural capital develop a specific kind of habitus, that is, modes of perceiving, thinking, and acting, remarkably well‐adjusted to the expectations of teachers and educational institutions. However, research has rarely tried to measure what we refer to as students' academic habitus to highlight the different types of habitus that students might express toward school. Drawing on data from secondary students in Luxembourg, we employ a latent class approach to operationalize, measure, and explore students' academic habitus. Our investigation comprises three main steps: First, we develop a multifaceted understanding of students' habitus integrating diverse dispositions toward school and learning; second, we identify different academic habitus types: the habitus of excellence, the habitus of goodwill and loyalty, and the habitus of disengagement. Third, we examine how the three habitus types relate to different axes of inequality: socioeconomic status, cultural capital, family employment, gender, and immigrant background. Our typology of habitus bridges the qualitative literature on habitus with existing quantitative operationalizations. The findings show that students with a habitus of excellence are likely to hail from families with favorable parental employment and high cultural involvement.
This mixed-method research study aims at an analysis of the role of teaching styles in the development of school alienation and behavioral consequences. Applying an in-depth design, this study combines a quantitative panel study, a student survey (grades 5–6), and qualitative focus groups with Luxembourgish primary school students (grade 6). Methodologically, we aim to demonstrate potentials and limits of integrating quantitative and qualitative research. Quantitative results show that teaching styles affect students’ alienation from teachers and from learning, and eventually from classroom participation and social behavior. Qualitative content analysis reveals that students characterize a fair teaching style as the equal treatment of all students regarding classroom rules and teachers’ empathy for students’ intentions.
2 January 2024 in British Journal of Educational Psychology
Background: Dealing with errors in the classroom is a crucial aspect of instructional quality and has multiple consequences for students' own dealing with errors, their learning and their achievement. The available literature on error climate indicates a paucity of research on the effects of perceived error climate on social aspects such as student–teacher relationships. Aims: The aim of this longitudinal study was to examine the relationship between error climate and alienation from teachers. Samples: We conducted a study with two measurement points in primary school (Grade 5 in 2017 and Grade 6 in 2018) and two samples ( N = 406 students in 29 classes in Switzerland and N = 345 students in 39 classes in Luxembourg). Methods: For scrutinizing the effect of error climate at T1 on alienation from teachers at T2, we used hierarchical linear modelling (students nested within classrooms). Results: For both samples, the results indicated that a positive error climate at T1 predicted less alienation from teachers at T2. We also found an effect of the shared error climate on alienation from teachers. Conclusions: The findings provide empirical evidence of the importance of improving how errors are handled in the classroom to prevent students' alienation from their teachers.
Recent research has highlighted the crucial role of affective-emotional factors in children’s and young people’s learning success. This study investigates the development of school enjoyment and its influence on academic achievement, focusing on gender differences. In stratified education systems, school transitions present a developmental challenge, requiring students to adapt to new school cultures and increased academic demands. This study focuses on the period from fourth grade in German elementary school to seventh grade in lower secondary school, a key phase for both educational and personal development. We used longitudinal data from the National Educational Panel Study (NEPS), which includes over N = 8000 students (51% female; Mage = 8.8 years in fourth grade, SD = 0.38). A dynamic panel model was used to assess school enjoyment across four time points, from grades four (2015/16) to grade seven (2018/19). The analysis revealed a steady decline in school enjoyment over time, with boys showing a more pronounced decrease than girls. Ordered logistic regression models demonstrated positive associations between school enjoyment and educational achievement, as measured by scores in German language and mathematics throughout lower secondary school. This study sheds light on the relationship between school enjoyment, gender, and academic performance, highlighting the crucial role of positive school experiences in promoting students’ well-being and academic success during this pivotal stage in education. Insights from this research can inform school policies, teacher training, and curriculum design, ensuring that educational systems are more inclusive, supportive, and effective.