The goal of this article is to detect structural damage in the presence of operational and environmental variations using vibration-based damage identification procedures. For this purpose, four machine learning algorithms are applied based on the auto-associative neural network, factor analysis, Mahalanobis distance, and singular value decomposition. A base-excited three-story frame structure was tested in laboratory environment to obtain time-series data from an array of accelerometers under several structural state conditions. Tests were performed with varying stiffness and mass conditions with the assumption that these sources of variability are representative of changing operational and environmental conditions. Damage is simulated through nonlinear effects introduced by a bumper mechanism that induces a repetitive, impact-type nonlinearity. This mechanism intends to simulate the cracks that open and close under dynamic loads or loose connections that rattle. The unique contribution of this study is a direct comparison of the four proposed machine learning algorithms that have been reported as reliable approaches to separate structural conditions with changes resulting from damage from changes caused by operational and environmental variations.
Bridges play a crucial role in modern societies, regardless of their culture, geographical location, or economic development. The safest, economical, and most resilient bridges are those that are well managed and maintained. In the last three decades, structural health monitoring (SHM) has been a promising tool in management activities of bridges as potentially it permits one to perform condition assessment to reduce uncertainty in the planning and designing of maintenance activities as well as to increase the service performance and safety of operation. The general idea has been the transformation of massive data obtained from monitoring systems and numerical models into meaningful information. To deal with large amounts of data and perform the damage identification automatically, SHM has been cast in the context of the statistical pattern recognition (SPR) paradigm, where machine learning plays an important role. Meanwhile, recent technologies have unveiled alternative sensing opportunities and new perspectives to manage and observe the response of bridges, but it is widely recognized that bridge SHM is not yet fully capable of producing reliable global information on the presence of damage . While there have been multiple review studies published on SHM and vibration-based structural damage detection for wider scopes, there have not been so many reviews on SHM of bridges in the context of the SPR paradigm. Besides, some of those reviews become obsolete quite fast, and they are usually biased towards applications falling outside of bridge engineering. Therefore, the main goal of this article is to summarize the concept of SHM and point out key developments in research and applications of the SPR paradigm observed in bridges in the last three decades, including developments in sensing technology and data analysis, and to identify current and future trends to promote more coordinated and interdisciplinary research in the SHM of bridges.
An important step for using time‐series autoregressive (AR) models for structural health monitoring is the estimation of the appropriate model order. To obtain an optimal AR model order for such processes, this article presents and discusses four techniques based on Akaike information criterion, partial autocorrelation function, root mean squared error, and singular value decomposition. A unique contribution of this work is to provide a comparative study with three different AR models that is carried out to understand the influence of the model order on the damage detection process in the presence of simulated operational and environmental variability. A three‐story base‐excited frame structure was used as a test bed in a laboratory setting, and data sets were measured for several structural state conditions. Damage was introduced by a bumper mechanism that induces a repetitive impact‐type nonlinearity. The operational and environmental effects were simulated by adding mass and by changing the stiffness properties of the columns. It was found that these four techniques do not converge to a unique solution, rather all require somewhat qualitative interpretation to define the optimal model order. The comparative study carried out on these data sets shows that the AR model order range defined by the four techniques provides robust damage detection in the presence of simulated operational and environmental variability.