April 15th, 2019: Notre-Dame Cathedral in Paris was burning, the spire collapsed on the nave, vaults crumbled and most of the timber roof was gone. In the post-disaster context, the authenticity and the monitoring of the archaeological remains are crucial for their potential reuse during reconstruction. This paper analyzes the collapsed transverse arch from the nave of Notre-Dame as a case study of reconstruction, using the digital twin framework. We propose four facets for the digital twin experiment—physical anastylosis, reverse engineering, spatio-temporal tracking of assets, and operational research—that are described in detail, while being assembled to support a hybrid reconstruction hypothesis. The digital twin can realize the parallel unfolding of physical-native and digital-native processes, while acquiring and storing heterogeneous information as semantically structured data. The results demonstrate that the proposed modeling method facilitates the formalization and validation of the reconstruction problem and increases solutions performances. As result, we present a digital twin framework application ranging from acquisition to data processing that informs a successful hybrid reconstruction hypothesis.
This paper describes a practical implementation of a CIDOC-CRM modeled virtual argumentation reconstruction model using the open-source DB Drupal. It describes a workflow for entering virtual reconstruction paradata, metadata and data in order to allow the tracing of knowledge provenance in reconstruction in CH. A case-study is presented of the documentation of a reconstruction of the Lioness Lintel (Hephaisteion, Athens).
In Notre-Dame de Paris’ digital twin, the massive data is characterized by its variability in terms of production and documentation. The question of provenance appears as the missing link in digital heritage data and a fortiori in the provenance of knowledge. The problem can be formulated as follows: the heterogeneity of data means variability as multi-device, multitemporal, multiscalar, with spatial granularity, and multi-layered and semantic complexity. The objective of this article is to improve the quality and consistency of paradata and to bridge the practical gap between mass 3D digitization and mass data enrichment in the data lineage of cultural heritage digital collections. FAIR principles, provenance, and context are keys in the data management workflows. We propose an innovative solution to integrate provenance and context seamlessly into these workflows, enabling more cohesive and reliable data enrichment. In this article, we use both conceptual modeling and quick prototyping: we posit that existing conceptual models can be used as complementary modules to document the provenance and context of research activity metadata. We focus on three models, namely the W7, the PROV ontology, and the CIDOC CRM. These models express different aspects of data and knowledge provenance. The use case from Notre-Dame de Paris’ research demonstrates the validity of the proposed hybrid modular conceptual modeling to dynamically manage the Provenance Level of Detail in cultural heritage data.
22 July 2016 in International Journal on Digital Libraries